5.1 Community Standards/Disciplinary Process
5.0 Community Standards Process
The MBA Community Standards disciplinary process reflects and safeguards the HBS Community Values, MBA Honor Code, and all other Standards of Conduct. It is designed to be fair and transparent to all students involved. MBA Program leadership, in consultation with the Chair of MBA Community Standards, may modify the disciplinary process as circumstances require. Students should familiarize themselves with the General Statement of Conduct in addition to the process described below.
Jurisdiction
For purposes of this section, reference to "HBS policies" include the Community Values, MBA Honor Code, Standards of Conduct, and al other policies contained in or incorporated by the MBA Student Handbook. Allegations of minor infractions are resolved through the Administrative Process set forth below. All other allegations are ordinarily referred to the Conduct Review Board (CRB); separate procedures apply for allegations arising under the Sexual Harassment or Other Sexual Misconduct policies and the Non-Discrimination and Anti-Bullying policies, as reflected in those sections of the Handbook. Students enrolled in a joint degree program also will be subject to any additional disciplinary processes set forth in their respective joint-degree handbook section(s).
Notification of Possible Violation
Reports of potential violations of the HBS policies should be directed to a member of the Community Standards staff. Potential violations may be reported by a number of different sources including, for example: faculty, staff, students, other members of the Harvard community, and the Harvard University Police Department (HUPD). Upon receipt of a report, a Community Standards staff member or designee (the Administrator) will conduct a preliminary review and gather information relevant to the concern. This process may include meeting with the reporter and consulting with faculty, staff, or other individuals who may have relevant information.
Students alleged to have violated HBS policies will be notified promptly, unless the allegations are found to lack sufficient merit to warrant further review or notification would create a risk of potential loss, destruction, or compromise of relevant information.
At the discretion of the MBA Program, interim measures may be imposed while a matter is under review. Such measures may include restrictions on participation in School activities or placement on an involuntary leave of absence.
Initial Review of Possible Violation
As part of the initial review, the student about whom allegations have been raised ordinarily will meet with the Administrator to discuss the allegations, learn about the disciplinary process, and provide relevant information. As appropriate, the Administrator may interview others who may have pertinent information. While students are not permitted to make audio and video recordings of any meetings related to the disciplinary process, they may take notes. Based on what is learned, the MBA Program Chair and a representative from MBA Program leadership will determine whether the matter will be handled through the Administrative Process or referred to the Conduct Review Board.
Administrative Process
For minor infractions, the MBA Program Chair and a representative from MBA Program leadership will review the information gathered during the initial review and determine whether a violation occurred. The Administrative Process is ordinarily reserved for matters involving less serious conduct or matters that, in the judgment of the MBA Program Chair and a representative from MBA Program leadership, can be appropriately addressed through educational or less serious sanctions. Within two (2) business days from the date on which they are notified, a student may provide a written statement in their own words for consideration as part of the review. If it is determined that a violation occurred, the MBA Program Chair and a representative from MBA Program leadership will determine the appropriate sanction(s). Sanctions may include, but are not limited to, a warning, temporary notation on student's transcript, probation, and/or community service.
Conduct Review Board Process
The Chair of MBA Community Standards (CCS) oversees the Conduct Review Board process with the support of the Administrator, including the investigation. In the steps outlined below, the person raising the allegation is the complainant and the person against whom the allegations were brought is the respondent. When circumstances warrant, for example in some plagiarism cases, the School may be the complainant.
Investigation
The CRB process begins with a formal investigation. The respondent and complainant (if applicable) may provide any relevant information or names of witnesses with direct knowledge of the situation. General character witnesses are not permitted. The Administrator then may act as a fact-finder or may appoint one or more people to serve as fact-finders. Fact-finders may be Harvard administrators or faculty members drawn from Harvard Business School or elsewhere. Fact-finders also may be independent contractors engaged by Harvard. Based on the initial review and follow-up interviews with individuals who may have pertinent information, the fact-finder will prepare an "Initial Fact-Finding Report" to share with the respondent and the CRB. After receiving the Initial Report, the respondent will have five (5) business days in which to submit a written response that will be shared with the CRB. The response must be written in the respondent’s own words. While the respondent may seek advice and support throughout the process, the respondent should not consult with others involved in the allegation.CRB Meeting
The CRB meets in a closed session to review the Initial Report and written response(s), and then interviews the respondent individually to ask any follow-up questions. Respondents may bring to the meeting with the CRB one member of the HBS community for support as a non-speaking observer.
The CRB also may ask others with knowledge of the situation to meet with the Board and answer questions.
If the CRB receives information supporting further allegations against the respondent that were not previously brought forward, the respondent will be informed and offered an opportunity to submit within three days an additional written response or, at the discretion of the CRB, invited to another closed session to discuss the additional allegations.
The CRB will vote to determine whether a violation occurred and what sanctions, if any, should be applied. The CRB applies a “preponderance of evidence” standard, meaning that the CRB will decide whether it is more likely than not that the respondent violated the School’s policies. The CRB’s decisions are based on a majority vote, with the Chair of MBA Community Standards voting only in the case of a tie.CRB Determination & Sanctioning
When it is determined that a violation occurred, the Administrator will share with the respondent, on behalf of the CRB, a "Draft Findings Report" describing the violation(s) and any applicable sanctions. The respondent may submit a written response within three (3) business days. The CRB will consider the respondent’s written response, if any, and then issue a "Final Determination Report" that states its conclusion on violations and any sanctions that should apply. The potential sanctions that may be imposed by the CRB are set forth in Section 5.3 Community Standards/Disciplinary Outcomes & Sanctions.Appeal
For matters where a respondent receives Suspension (with or without a recommendation to dismiss or expel) as a sanction, the respondent has the right to appeal the CRB findings within seven (7) business days if the respondent has substantive and relevant new evidence related to the facts of the case that was not available at the time of the CRB's decision, and that may change the outcome of the decision. The appeal should include the new evidence and an explanation of why it was not previously available. Disagreement with the findings or the decision of the CRB is not, by itself, grounds for appeal. Appeals must be submitted to the Dean, and the Dean's decision on the appeal is final. If the violations or sanctions are not upheld, then the Dean will determine next steps or new sanctions.
Protection of Privacy
The MBA Program and CRB will treat the information they receive with appropriate sensitivity. In addition to the CRB members, the MBA Program Chair and a representative from MBA Program leadership will receive copies of reports. Individuals who are witnesses in an investigation also are asked to treat information as confidential and are given only the context and information needed so that they can answer any questions they are asked.
Throughout the Community Standards/disciplinary process, appropriate HBS faculty and staff members, as well as others at the University may be consulted on or informed of the case and its progress.
Observation of a Possible Violation
When a possible violation of Community Values, Honor Code, all other Standards of Conduct, or another HBS policy is observed, members of the HBS community are encouraged to report a possible violation to a Community Standards staff member.
Non-Retaliation
HBS prohibits retaliation against any individual who, in good faith, reports a potential violation of HBS policy, participates in a disciplinary process, serves as a witness, provides information, or otherwise assists in the review of a matter. Retaliation includes conduct that reasonably would discourage a person from reporting concerns or participating in a disciplinary process. Allegations of retaliation may constitute a separate violation of HBS policy and may result in disciplinary action.
Support through the Community Standards/Disciplinary Process
Students may receive support through the disciplinary process through a variety of sources including the Ombuds, MBA Student and Academic Services, the Counseling and Mental Health Service at HUHS (CAMHS), or the University Chaplain's office.
Ombuds
The Ombuds (login required) is a neutral and confidential third party who can support a student in the following ways if they are involved in a disciplinary process:
help the student understand the disciplinary process and the options available
provide a sounding board as the student considers and develops their response
MBA Student and Academic Services
The MBA Student and Academic Services (login required) team provides support and advising to HBS students facing a wide range of challenges, including those related to a disciplinary process.
Harvard University Health Services Counseling and Mental Health Services (CAMHS)
CAMHS is a unit of the Harvard University Health Services that provides counseling and mental health support services to students.
Chaplain Resources
Harvard Chaplains are available to offer religious, spiritual, and moral support for all members of the University community.
Duration of Community Standards/Disciplinary Process
Cases ordinarily are considered as quickly as is reasonably possible, given the need to investigate matters carefully. The length of the process depends on the complexity of the case, the number of necessary interviews, and scheduling availability. If the case is referred to the CRB, the Administrator will schedule the meeting as soon as reasonably possible given member availability.
Members of the Conduct Review Board (CRB)
The CRB is a committee comprised of faculty members, students and staff members. For each case, a smaller committee is appointed from the CRB, comprised of three faculty (including the CCS), three students, one senior staff member, and one administrator to the Board (the Administrator), who is a non-voting member. This allows for flexibility to avoid conflicts and to schedule cases as quickly as possible. Students who serve on the CRB may include RC, EC, Doctoral, and Joint Degree students. At any given time, if there is an uptick in cases falling under the jurisdiction of the CRB, the MBA Program may add former and/or new members to the CRB to accommodate the additional caseload.
The following individuals oversee or have roles in the formal HBS disciplinary process:
Chair, MBA Community Standards (CCS)
Professor Sandra Sucher, ssucher@hbs.edu
Oversees the Community Values Program
Oversees the disciplinary process, including:
Managing the work of the administrator as it relates to the CRB
Serving as chair of the Conduct Review Board
Overseeing the recruitment of CRB members
Community Standards Staff/Administrators to the Board
Associate Director, MBA Community Standards and Program Services
Benjamin Longstreth, blongstreth@hbs.edu
Senior Associate Director, MBA Program Services
Sandra Feliz, sfeliz@hbs.edu
Senior Director, MBA Program Office
Dana Pratt, dpratt@hbs.edu
Serve as primary point of contact regarding potential conduct violations involving students
Manage fact-finding process regarding potential conduct violations (unless otherwise delegated)
Manage case-related information for the CCS and CRB
Monitor student compliance with sanctions and petitions to return to HBS