Are existing institutions up to the task of preparing the labor force for emerging jobs while also addressing longstanding issues of participation and productivity? AI only raises the value of human skills in meeting the challenge. Drawing on her leadership experience across business, government, higher education, and philanthropy, Pritzker discusses what it will take to adapt the complex workforce development system to provide maximum access to the benefits of a radically shifting economy.
Transcript
Penny Pritzker: “You can’t do this work alone. It only works when employers and educators and civic leaders are all at the table and have a shared set of objectives and goals, and that it’s matching the real labor-market demand. But progress typically comes from leaders who know how to build coalitions, create urgency, and drive change across organizational boundaries. And fundamentally, another thing that’s true is talent is a regional competitiveness issue. Communities that can connect their people to opportunity and help workers continuously build skills are better positioned to attract investment and economic growth.”
Joe Fuller: AI is changing work, but it’s also forcing us to take a fresh look at the institutions that prepare people for work. For decades, employers, educators, and policymakers have struggled to align training with labor-market demand and build pathways to economic mobility. What is new is the pace and reach of AI and the need for leaders to engage with the technology, directly enough to understand its implications for work and management.
Welcome to the Managing the Future of Work podcast from Harvard Business School. I’m your host, Harvard Business School professor and nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. It’s my pleasure to welcome Penny Pritzker to the podcast. Penny is an unusually well-positioned partner for this conversation. Her longstanding interest in workforce issues grew out of her experiences in her family’s Hyatt Hotel business. Her career spans entrepreneurship, philanthropy and government service as the 38th U.S. Secretary of Commerce. She is the founder and chair of PSP Partners and Senior Fellow of the Harvard Corporation, her alma mater’s governing board. She’s active in workforce initiatives in her hometown of Chicago and at the national level. We’ll discuss what this moment demands and the launch of Raise US, a newly created bipartisan initiative working with states to develop novel approaches to workforce development in the age of AI. Well, Secretary Penny Pritzker, welcome to the Managing the Future of Work podcast.
Pritzker: Joe, thanks so much for having me. Really pleased to be here.
Fuller: Penny, you and I have known each other for quite some time, and you’ve had an interest in workforce and workforce development issues as long as I’ve known you, before your service in the federal government and in many other roles. Can you tell us a little bit about how you gained that interest?
Pritzker: Supporting our workers has been a passion of mine for decades. The passion comes from knowing, frankly, that I’ve been very blessed, but we’re not doing enough. We’re just not doing enough in my mind to help our workers react to the fast-moving changes in technology and the changes in demands by employers. I’ve always been interested in education. And then as I got more and more involved in government and policy, I cared more and more about how are we preparing our population for the opportunities that exist in our economy. And whether that was helping create Skills for Chicagoland’s Future or Skills for America’s Future or as Secretary of Commerce, I created the first Skills for Business in concert with then Vice President Biden and the Education and Labor departments, where we refocused the $600 million that was being spent at the time on federal training to be more effective and more influenced by what employers needed in terms of making sure that the training was job driven and employer led, if you will. And then I got involved with the Council on Foreign Relations. They asked me to lead a task force on The Work Ahead, which became a roadmap for the Trump One administration and the Biden administration on workforce. And then in Chicago, it’s been something that we’ve pursued through P33, which is really focused on workers in the tech community and then our work from the foundation. So for me, this has been something that has been a through line for me for decades. One of the reasons that I am so interested in workforce is that I relate to the person in my family who is the immigrant. My great-grandfather came to the United States, and but for access to training and education, my family doesn’t grow into become the family that it is. And my great-grandfather and his wife came with nothing. They did not speak the language. They taught themselves English. But they understood that they were fortunate enough to have opportunity. And they even started something called the Nickel Club, where they would save a nickel each week to help other immigrants. That is very much a part of my DNA and very much motivates me to want to pursue creating opportunity.
Fuller: Penny, you’ve been involved, the driving force behind several different efforts in Chicago, the Chicago Talent Challenge or Skills for Chicago, P33, you mentioned. Could you just walk us through each of those briefly and describe what they do? And then maybe you could talk a little bit about what you’re learning from those efforts—what’s working, what’s not.
Pritzker: Sure. So first of all, the Chicago Talent Challenge is really a, it’s an open call in a certain sector of the economy for a philanthropic gift of $5 million that would support an effort to train people in Chicago for a specific opportunity. And the first winner of that was the Chicago community colleges, and the Cook County Hospital teamed up and said, “We want to create a new training program to train workers to fill our vacant positions and fill the positions that we’re paying agencies for. And that’s the idea of the Chicago Talent Challenge—to use capital to create programs that are then going to be long-term self-sustaining. P33 is really a fundamental effort in the city of Chicago that I co-led the creation of when I came back from Commerce. The fundamental thesis of P33 is that Chicago was punching below its weight in terms of the tech economy, that we had great universities and we had two Department of Energy labs, and that we had great innovators and entrepreneurs, but somehow that wasn’t coming together to put us as a leader as a top 10 city in the United States in terms of technology. And so that effort has actually paid off and really one of the big wins there is, is that Chicago has become a center for quantum. And so with that comes the need for training. So what have I learned from being focused on these things is the number one thing, that you can’t do this work alone. It only works when employers and educators and civic leaders are all at the table and have a shared set of objectives and goals, and that it’s matching the real labor-market demand. The second is leadership really matters—especially you need big corporations and training institutions to be involved. But progress typically comes from leaders who know how to build coalitions, create urgency, and drive change across organizational boundaries. I would say the third thing is the most durable ideas pay as much attention to sustainability as they do program design. And what I mean by that is that, if an initiative cannot develop a long-term business model—like I was talking about the business model of the community colleges and the Cook County Hospital—it’s very hard to achieve scale and also to attract others who will replicate your model. So it’s important how you design your programs and who the players are that are involved. A couple other things are, the most successful initiatives are designed around skills that employers desperately need filled and the opportunities that employers are prepared to create. And fundamentally another thing that’s true is talent is a regional competitiveness issue. Communities that can connect their people to opportunity and help workers continuously build skills are better positioned to attract investment and economic growth.
Fuller: That’s a really terrific list and is confirmed by multiple different pieces of research we’ve done at Harvard over the years. But I’m curious about why do we need special interventions? Why do we need outside impetus so often to get that team on the field? You would have thought that this would be, to borrow a computing term, kind of a self-healing network, that employers would understand that if they consistently don’t have a supply of the talent they need, they’re going to have to do something differently. And that if educators consistently saw people either not ending up in meaningful employment or being unable to complete programs, that they would start investigating why that was, but that doesn’t seem to happen very naturally. It often takes someone like yourself who’s credible with all parties to intervene and try to get the team on the field playing in the same style. Why has this been such a durable, intractable problem?
Pritzker: You have to bring employers together to compare what their needs are. That doesn’t just happen, right? If I’m the chief human resource officer or the chief people person for a business, my No. 1 job is that business. I’m not thinking about my geography or I’m thinking about my company and I’m not thinking about my community. I’m trying to solve a very specific problem. So there isn’t a natural catalyst for companies to come together and say collectively, “If we did this kind of training, we’d all be better.” So the market doesn’t naturally come together in that respect. For the community colleges or the other training institutions, it’s hard for them to just see the marketplace. That’s not their first line of business. Theirs is in education. So you need a catalyst to bring the employers and the training institutions together, and they need to assess where can we make a difference at scale and how can we do that and do that successfully? I’ll go back to our Chicago Talent Challenge. The winner was this collaboration between the community colleges and Cook County. Well, what’s happened is other large healthcare systems have seen the success of this idea and this program, and they’ve now gone to the community colleges and said, “How can we do that as well?” And so they are now, that thing is scaling much beyond what was initially anticipated. That’s what you want to have happen, but it’s hard for that other healthcare system to know that this is a possibility. It’s hard for the community colleges to know which hospitals or healthcare systems need this kind of training. And what’s particularly interesting is that a lot of that training is going on on-site in the hospital systems. There’s some collective training going on at the geography of the community college as opposed to… and then some of it is happening in the healthcare systems. Well, that’s not something you would know as a marketplace.
Fuller: We’re talking at the end of the summer just before Labor Day in 2026, and it’s a unique moment, let me suggest, in the labor market. It’s unusual to see such widespread anxiety about the future of work, about the future of entry-level jobs. How different do you think this is from past transitions?
Pritzker: I think we cannot ignore AI. We’re going through a major step function change in terms of the way work is going to occur or is occurring. We’re working much more with technology tools, with agents, and I think that the workforce needs to be comfortable with that. And if you’re someone who’s growing up with the development of AI, and it’s part of your education system, that’s great. If you’re someone like me, where I went to school typing on a typewriter. So there’s an enormous need for skill development. I think this change is as significant as when we went from an agrarian society to an industrial society—a massive change in almost every area. I mean, coding is seeing it the most significantly right now, but it’s affecting work in every kind of sector of the economy that I’m exposed to at least. And I don’t care who you are, you could be the CEO, you could be the president of a university, you could be a great professor like you are, you could be someone who’s an analyst in an investment bank. We all have to learn new skills, and we have to embrace the new technologies to understand how they can both help us individually and help our organizations.
Fuller: So Penny, tell me a little bit about your own use of AI. I know you’ve spent some time at a school across the river from ours. Tell us about that, why you did that and how that has advanced your thinking and your personal use of AI.
Pritzker: Well, Joe, as you and I have talked about, I mean, I think that it’s important that all of us embrace a growth mindset throughout our career. I felt that I had plateaued in my ability to see what was possible with AI. And I did look at the Harvard Business School courses. Mitch Weiss teaches a great course for executives, but it just didn’t work out schedule-wise. So I took a three-day course at MIT and really what it opened my eyes to is that agentic AI is the future. And as a leader, I needed to learn not only how to create an agent and what the pros and cons of agents are, but also to understand how do you manage agents and how do you have your workforce work side by side with agents? What are the risks—the risks to your company, th e risks to society? I think that we as leaders need to embrace change, and we need then to help our people and invest in our people so that they’re best positioned to grow and innovate and compete. I feel that’s a responsibility as an employer.
Fuller: Well, that certainly validates something that Mitch Weiss says, which is AI is really learned with your fingers, not with your brain. You’ve got to use it and know how it’s working and how to get value out of it by doing.
Pritzker: Very much. I have a much better understanding of potential. And what’s so exciting to me is, we are not a large company. We’re about 100 people in our central office. I’m watching people create products that we’re using internally that are absolutely making us better, more effective. We are able to punch way above our weight because we’re leveraging agents and AI. And people are not being unemployed. We’re doing more because of it.
Fuller: So we constantly talk about reskilling as a priority, but who owns responsibility for that? Is it the employer’s obligation to be providing that? Is this something that people just need to embrace on their own and engage in the multiple, actually quite good free resources? Doesn’t somebody have to really drive this? And if so, who do you think that should be?
Pritzker: Well, normally it would be government—bring a bunch of experts together and really look at what’s happening to our society and perhaps say that we might rethink the way that we’re doing, let’s call it K–12 education. And we might be thinking more about the training that’s possible. Do you need a college education for every single type of work? And if not, what are the options? And this is normally would be something you would imagine a federal government taking a lead on. What’s happening is it really becomes incumbent upon communities. It becomes incumbent upon employers. It becomes incumbent upon your community colleges to try and sort this out or your major universities. But getting that word out on a national level is hard. And asking someone who’s sitting on the south or west side of Chicago to go figure that out for themselves, that is really brutal. One of the things that I’ve focused my whole life on is this notion of building opportunity. It’s what drives me, it’s what I enjoy the most. And I grew up in a family where that was expressed as building businesses. And I saw how businesses could provide economic opportunity. I watched my parents build a hotel business from nothing and they raised me with “To whom much is given,” much is expected. And I watched the bellman become the general manager of a hotel. It’s very hard for an individual to figure this out all on their own. And normally you’ve got governments that help get out the word about here’s what we’ve learned from experts, but that’s just not happening right now.
Fuller: When you analogize between the industrial revolution, the transformation of the US economy from an agrarian economy to a more urbanized industrial one, that raises the question, what other things might we need to support this transition beyond reskilling? Because if you look at the history of industrialization, what followed? Well, high schools followed. There was no such thing as high school in 1870 unless you were some moneyed Boston or New York family sending your children off to intellectual finishing school. Trade unions ultimately emerged because of things like workplace safety, reasonable working hours, child labor, and whatnot. As you think forward broadly, what other types of things do you think we’re going to be obliged to look at beyond just hoping that this transition is easy enough for enough workers and companies and educators to advance their pace of taking ownership over this transition?
Pritzker: I think that’s a really, really important question. I mean, I think there’s a significant role for public policy to play in a number of things. First is we need a data infrastructure that helps students and institutions and employers make better decisions. We need easier visibility into what’s possible. We should know which programs lead to jobs, what credentials produce strong earnings outcomes, what talent shortages are emerging, what’s available for free—whether it’s provided by a company or provided by a university. So one is data and infrastructure. The second is, we should reward outcomes, not just participation. And funding should increasingly support programs that demonstrate success in placing students into good jobs with opportunities for advancement. I mean, we need to focus not just on enrolling and completion, but on employment and economic mobility. And the third is, I think there’s a role for policy and encouraging employers to become active partners in workforce development and be sustained partners in workforce development. Ultimately, I believe the goal is simple. Every student should leave an educational experience with a credible pathway to opportunity.
Fuller: We certainly have two very important experiments underway right now on that. The higher-ed funding in the state of Texas is now largely affected by the economic outcomes of various programs. And they’re seeing very significant growth in more practically oriented programs that are often described as non-credit programs. They’re not academic programs. They’re directly related to skilled trades, for example. And of course, now we’ve got the very early days of so-called workforce Pell Grants, which also have such a measurement. It’s also kind of interesting how in some ways on the employer front, we have a pretty good sense of what works. If you look at states as varied as South Carolina to Wisconsin, fairly limited tax credits for having an enrolled work-based learner, usually an apprentice, seem to move the needle, but for some reason that isn’t getting taken up by a lot of states or being permanently funded when it does have a pretty good track record.
Pritzker: Do you think that’s budget related or is it policy related?
Fuller: Well, in my conversations, particularly with governors and their workforce boards, it often is a policy issue. It’s awkward. Often it’s bigger employers who will be willing to try these things because they have a training infrastructure. So what are we doing for small business becomes a question. Obviously, a lot of states are concerned about their fiscal situations and trying to be as concerned as they can about adding new programs that could get big. And then you get into the whole allocation of things like healthcare spending between the federal government and state governments. Let’s revert maybe to a more hopeful conversation. You’ve become involved with Raise US, as have I, which is a new initiative to look at what programs can work at state level on skills and on employability with a particular emphasis on the impact of AI. It’s founded by one of your successors as Secretary of Commerce, former [Rhode Island] Governor Gina Raimondo. We’re proud to claim both you and Secretary Raimondo as Harvard undergraduates. And Governor Eric Holcomb, recently governor of Indiana, who I got to know when he was serving. Tell me a little bit about why you were attracted to that and what do you think are the most important priorities or gaps that they should be focused on going forward?
Pritzker: Well, first of all, the reason I really was excited to get involved is what you talked about: leadership. I think the two former governors who are leading this effort are the right people at the right moment. Remember, the focus is, it has a simple premise. America has a technology strategy for AI, but we don’t have a people strategy for AI. And it’s fundamentally something that we need. And then I think it’s focused on practical outcomes. And being rooted in results is so important. They’re looking to build a workforce infrastructure for workers to provide training and transition and help individuals thrive in the AI economy. So you’re bringing together the governors, the employers, and the educators, beginning in four states: Arkansas, Connecticut, Maryland, and Utah. And I think they have a 20-plus employer coalition. And I think it has the opportunity to reimagine our education system. It can go beyond just skilling for the moment, but I think by virtue of working closely with these states—and I believe that the idea is that each year they’ll add a few more states so that they’ll pilot and expand and pilot and expand, which I think makes total sense. And the other thing that excites me about what they’re doing is they’re focused on scale. It’s not, I’m going to try to train hundreds of workers, but this is about ultimately tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of people, which I think is essential and is hard, but they’ve raised significant dollars to begin. And I think that also the other thing that they’re doing is collecting data and really using, as I said, I think we need a data infrastructure. So I’m excited for this effort because it’s nonpartisan.
Fuller: Well, I think it has the opportunity to be a very important catalyst for documenting what works and for observing experiments and learning from them irrespective of whether they’re a success. I have a very valued colleague at Harvard Business School I’ve taught with for many years, Amy Edmondson, and she has this theory of the right type of wrong. You can benefit a lot from trying something and learning from it, even though it didn’t give you confirmation of your hypothesis or the ROI you’d hoped. And what we really need to do now in this new world is learn what works. And if you’re really going to get there, you’re going to occasionally stub your toe, and you’re going to have to grin and bear it, as opposed to just turn everything from a pilot into a scaled program, irrespective of its marginal performance.
Pritzker: I think that’s exactly right. And I think one of the important things is evaluation. And I think they’re committed very much to not just piloting but evaluating; and taking what works and scaling that. And I think getting folks like yourself involved who can help them see through the morass of information and understand what works is really important—people like yourself who are used to looking at research results in this field. I think the other thing that’s really interesting about it is, it’s four very different states with very different populations with different educational leadership in those states, different governors. And I think that’s important. We have to acknowledge what works in one state may not be exactly what’s going to work in another state or the way it’s put together may be different. So I think that I’m excited for this effort and look forward to participating.
Fuller: I can’t wait to see what happens. Penny, as you think about maybe let’s say 10 years from now, if we’ve weathered this storm, what’s the labor market going to look like? If you could wave the proverbial magic wand and get two or three major outcomes, what would be your wish list?
Pritzker: Well, I think my hope is, is that we have a dynamic labor force that is able to work side by side with AI and agents, that we’re partnering with technology. So that’s one thing. The second is, is that the process for a person to pursue opportunity and careers is more transparent. In other words, that the data that somehow we’ve created, maybe it’s state by state, clearer data about where there’s opportunity. And the third is, is that we’re also, the hypothesis about what is effective training for different sectors is clearer. I don’t know about you, Joe. I have more and more people who ask me, “Well, what should my kids study in this new era?” And I think we need greater clarity about that. Twenty years ago, if you went into computer science or you were a doctor or there were a few careers that it was absolutely clear if you could pass through and accomplish what was required in your studies, that you were going to have a successful career. Today, people are very uncertain about that. And I think that we need to help our communities understand what is that. And that’s where both research comes in, where government policy comes in, where collecting data is important. And it can’t be just something that we’re all sort of guessing at, which is, it feels like we’re in a messy moment of understanding when it comes to that.
Fuller: Well, it’s certainly early innings, and people who are making very confident forecasts about the future confuse me because we’re barely in the bottom of the second inning of this particular game.
Pritzker: Yeah. And I think another thing that’s important is we need to really look at our safety net and make sure it’s working for all Americans. And I feel like that is something that is under siege at this moment as well. So there’s a big role for public policy. Another thing, we talk about AI from the standpoint of how do we make sure that AI is being used for good and that the downsides are being managed. And how do we develop AI where there’s trust? And I think there’s just a lot of work that needs to go on in that respect. And I think government, that’s another place where government and expertise are really important.
Fuller: Well, Secretary of Commerce, Penny Pritzker, proud Harvard graduate, delighted to have you on the Managing the Future of Work podcast and continue to look forward to all the change and innovation you’re helping to introduce to the Chicagoland area.
Pritzker: Joe, thank you so much for inviting me, and I’m so excited that we were able to have this conversation.
Fuller: We hope you enjoyed the Managing the Future of Work podcast. If you haven’t already, please subscribe and rate the show wherever you listen to podcasts. You can find out more about the Managing the Future of Work Project at our website at hbs.edu/managingthefutureofwork. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter.
