Corner office churn is up as demands multiply. Heidrick & Struggles' CEO explains what CVs leave out and why flexibility and organizational fit matter more as AI and global volatility undercut the predictive power of past performance. Also, AI-enhanced recruiting and lifelong learning.
Transcript
Joe Fuller: How much has the job of corporate CEO really changed in the last couple of decades? Research on top executive roles shows a shift: less emphasis on narrow technical credentials, more on judgment, adaptability, and cross‑functional leadership. The remit is also expanding, as strategy, geopolitics, social expectations, technology, and talent all converge on the corner office. And in a post‑AI economy, algorithms won’t just inform decision; they’ll increasingly influence who is identified, chosen, and evaluated for the top job.
Welcome to the Managing the Future of Work podcast from Harvard Business School. I’m your host, Harvard Business School professor and nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, Joe Fuller. I’m pleased to welcome Tom Monahan, CEO of Heidrick & Struggles, one of the world’s leading executive recruiting firms. Tom’s got a long history of leadership in consulting, technology, and workforce development. Prior to joining Heidrick in 2024, he was president and CEO of DeVry University, where he still serves on the board. Prior to DeVry, he was the longtime CEO of the Corporate Executive Board, or CEB, now part of the Gartner Group. We’ll talk about the economic and social forces reshaping leadership. We’ll look at how the business of finding leaders is changing, and what boards and CEOs now expect from the people they hire. We’ll explore how data and AI are reshaping the C‑suite and CEO selection processes and how that affects the wider workforce, from internal succession to skills development. And we’ll look at what really distinguishes leaders who can steer organizations—and their people—through constant disruption. Welcome to the Managing the Future of Work podcast, Tom.
Tom Monahan: Thanks, Joe. I’m excited to be here.
Fuller: Well, Tom, I think we should start maybe by talking about your path of work before we get to the future of work. You’re now the CEO of Heidrick & Struggles, the powerhouse executive search and leadership company, but you’ve taken a bit of a winding path to get there. I’ve known you quite some time, it seems, but share with our listeners your career path.
Monahan: Early career, started out in consulting for what became Accenture, and did some consulting there and at Deloitte and a stint in a nonprofit that took a look at the global economy and the U.S. economy. I spent a little more than 20 years building and spent a good chunk of that time leading a company called CEB, which built data and content-rich products for the C-suite of large companies globally. My first CEO gig. We had a lot of fun building as a growth company. It became a pretty substantial company, and we merged into what became modern Gartner. Since then, I was executive chairman of a company called ProKarma, which is a technology company owned by Carlyle. And then I was president and CEO and still vice chair of DeVry, the education company, and transitioned out of that role coming up on two and a half years ago. And not too long after that, the folks at Heidrick called. So I’ve been here for two years. It’s incredibly high-impact client work. And you kind of get to do great work with great people for great people, which is all you can ask for.
Fuller: That’s a winning combination. You will, of course, be familiar with the executive search industry, the leadership consulting industry that Heidrick’s a leader in. How’s it different today than 10 years ago, 20 years ago? Certainly, a lot of people’s experience with firms like that is episodic. Maybe they get asked if they’re interested in opportunity or they’re hired, but they don’t really know, I think, the modern state of the sector. Maybe you could update us on that.
Monahan: I always said I’ve had 25 years of experience with Heidrick—23 as a client, and two as a colleague. I think the biggest change in the industry—you could date this to the at-scale adoption of LinkedIn, where, if you go back sort of 20 years, Joe, I knew how to find you, you knew how to find me, but neither one of us were visible to the whole world. The talent population became very visible to anybody who wanted to see and find and learn about people in a pretty material way that changed over the course of five to 10 years. And so the industry, which always operated in a two-sided manner—so serving clients and having connectivity to great candidates—became ever more client focused. So our great people spend a lot of time saying, “Okay, Ms./Mr. client, Ms./Mr. board member, Ms./Mr. CEO, Ms./Mr. head of HR, what’s your strategy? Let’s really get clear on your objectives, on your goals, on your priorities, on your culture, on how the future’s going to be different than the past, how this challenge you’ve got right now is going to make your future.” And that leads to both—if you think of our core executive search business—great outcomes, because we’re getting closer to really understanding the client well, and, therefore, really understanding the objective of any search or succession process and understanding the cultural markers are going to make someone successful or not in that role. If clients are turning to us not just for a search, but actually to construct a high performing leadership team that has search components, it has executive development components, it has succession management components, it has assessment components, it has interim talent components. And Heidrick has resources to help a client achieve that overall objective across that spectrum.
Fuller: Well, my memory is that Hoffman started LinkedIn in, like, 2004. So we’re more than 20 years after that innovation. And we’re, of course, in the era now in the winter of ’26, where we’re really beginning to see, at least in our estimation at our project, that companies are now beginning to go to the next level and they’re thinking about AI—that they’re beginning to more aggressively deploy agentic systems. They’ve also begun to do the hard work of cleaning up their data to make it usable by AI. I think a lot of early experiments really [were a] failure of data, as opposed to failure of technology. Are you beginning to pick that up in a significant way in your searches when you’re working with a client? What are people asking about? Is the language changing at all? Is the pattern of demand beginning to reshape itself around the realities of AI?
Monahan: I think that’s a yes. I’d say we’re just now peeking over the boundary into what I’d call the fourth-ish era of the AI revolution. The first was using machine learning, RPA [robotic process automation], earlier iterations. Heidrick had an AI practice in 2014. It was more confined to certain industries, more confined to certain processes, but saying, “Take this at-scale process and bring RPA to it because it’s error-prone and expensive. We want it to be repeatable and scalable in a way it’s not right now.” The second stage was in the immediate aftermath of the first consumer-grade LLM in October, November 2022, where suddenly there was an enormous Cambrian explosion of activity. Like: “We need experiments. We need pilots. We’ve got to look busy. We got to have a lot of stuff going on.” And in our world, that showed up a little bit as, “Hey, get me an AI, head of AI,” where every company in the world shows up and says, “We need someone with 10 years’ experience in large language models.” And you say, “There’s, like, 18 of them at four university labs, and there’s 10,000 companies that need them. So just supply and demand. What are you really trying to get done?” The third phase was—and I think we’re deep in this right now—where every industry now has a predictable set of high-value use cases that they’re just working down. They’re working down a list. And most of those are taking work that is either miserable for humans to do or expensive for humans to do or error-prone for humans to do. I call that the third era—the era where companies are working really hard to move the AI story from the CEO’s earnings call script to the CFO’s earnings call script. The fourth era that we’ve entered now—and again, we’re just peeking over the fence into it—is clients are coming to us and saying, “We need leaders who will come in and help us understand what competitive and comparative advantage looks like.” It can show up as “find leaders”—not AI people, but people who are AI-fluent and can conceptualize and deliver new business models using a new age of general-purpose technology. It also leads to questions like, “Are we built right to do that? Do we have the right organization structure? Do I have the right kind of corporate culture to adapt to a new technology being deployed at scale that is not a vertical software program?” It’s early, and it’s showing up more in conversations around, “Show me someone who can be a head of product who can really understand what is it that only humans can deliver? What is it AI can deliver? Where can other forms of technology come together? How do these things mix up in a way that provides us defensible comparative advantage?” And I think that’s the era we’re going to be moving into over the next year.
Fuller: I would say that our sense of the market parallels that. We’re getting questions at the project from companies about how they should be rethinking effectively the way they manage work generally, how they do task allocation. Just as a quick aside, I certainly have been telling companies to rethink the way they form teams, and that they actually want to have a higher diversity of age in a lot of teams. A lot of teams are ... the people at the director level are going to do this project and report to an EVP what they found, as opposed to, we’re going to take people with that deep domain knowledge so they can spot a hallucination or spot a highly original output from an AI with the people who are very technically comfortable with that. Very often, the first might be a 20-year company veteran or interview veteran, and the next person might be the young person recently out of university or something. So what you’re really talking about is how to manage work in the future, not how to manage AI in the future. It’s going to require a rethink of essentially all the fundamental processes that relate to human assets: measurement, development, retention, leading them. So it’s going to be a remarkably interesting time. How do you think it’s going to affect your core business? As a CEO, when you’re sitting with your team? How do you talk about how this is going to affect Heidrick’s positioning and what the key choices you’re going to face are?
Monahan: We spend a lot of time thinking about categories of value that were impossible for us to access before, or prohibitively expensive for us to access before. I’ll give you a small example. If you take someone who’s been a public-company CEO for a period of time, you have got a definitive baseball card, a definitive clear U.S. GAAP [generally accepted accounting practices], SEC-registrant set of outcomes that they can represent. And, therefore, if one of our clients says, “Well, show me people who’ve done these things,” we can say, “Okay, if you’re fishing in a pool of proven public-company CEOs, we can show you.” Otherwise, there’s always going to be some sort of inductive leap. If they’ve been in a private setting, they’ve been running a sub[sidiary] of that, running a division in a cross-functional role, that clear baseball card doesn’t exist. That clear, these are the outcomes, growth, profit, capital efficiency, whatever, transformations delivered, all that. And AI lets us do more work to say, “Let’s assemble an ever-richer dossier of performance data on people for whom that was limited.” You’re just able to access new categories of data that round out our ability, to round out our understanding of a candidate so that we can better advise a client. Second category—we can always ask questions—we have data that we like to think we interrogate, and we like to think we bring to life. But this still lets us access more of the data, append it across platforms, bring meaning out of it in new ways. So first is, what are new categories of value? Second is, what are new insights from data? Third is, what are businesses that structurally either were too expensive for us to deliver or too expensive for the client to buy? Our first instinct sometimes is to go to, “We’re going to save so much time.” And colleagues sometimes hear that as, “They don’t need me anymore.” As opposed to, “There are dozens of use cases that we’ve looked at and said we can’t afford to do that. Client wants us to do what we can’t. Client can’t pay what we would need to do to deliver it.” And going back and saying, “Well, we just moved the supply curve on every human-intensive piece of knowledge work on the planet Earth. And that’s going to keep moving. What should we be doing that we, on the old supply curve, didn’t think about?” To some degree, our core executive search and our succession management businesses are prediction businesses. We’re helping the client decide whether candidate A, B, or C is most likely to succeed in this role. And the more data you can bring to bear, the richer that data, the better your prediction should be able to come, and the more you can test them across time. And then third, just pulling it back and saying, “If the supply curve moved pretty radically for knowledge work, what categories of knowledge work had we ruled out or had the client ruled out?”
Fuller: How do you think a client should evaluate a search provider when you think about what a client ought to be looking for beyond the fee and how long it took? But what are the more settled enduring elements of the value proposition that they ought to direct their attention to?
Monahan: I think our best work comes out when our teams get the client to think very hard around how will the organization look one year, two year, three years out if we get the right leader into this role? A priori, don’t start looking at Joe versus Tom yet. Ask the question, “It’s December 2028. What will be different about this function, this division, this company because we had the right leader in place?” And that can be a strategic question, it can be a productivity question, it can be an innovation question. But getting them thinking about that in advance, because three equally excellent candidates could deliver that at three very different organizations. What change will they drive? What would be the most important marker of their success? And then listening to us as to how they can evaluate candidates against that objective as opposed to speed, certainty. I mean, all that stuff is important, and we do pay real attention to that. But I think our highest-impact work begins and ends with alignment with the client around what impact they’re hoping to accomplish. They should judge us both by, did we help them get clear on that front, and did we deliver someone who actually drove that transformation?
Fuller: Are there things that you see pretty consistently spread over your portfolio of mandates that are gaining share, if you will, that your clients are asking for more of, more regularly? Are there four or five sine qua nons that, if you don’t have that type of skill or background, that you’re essentially going to be excluded from consideration for a lot of roles? What are the difference makers in terms of selecting candidates?
Monahan: We’ll do thousands upon thousands of searches and successions in a year, so we have some scale data on that. Let’s take boards of directors, who are the hiring manager, if you will, for a CEO. I do think the pandemic era changed—and our data backs this up—changed the way people think. And I think the way I always think about this is, let’s imagine we’re on a board. It’s December 2019. We’re sitting around where our amazing CEO has retired, she’s led the company through an incredible period, and we’re starting to say, “Well, what’s the next CEO going to have to contend with?” I am reasonably certain our list would not have included pandemic, supply-chain problems, war for talent. We wouldn’t have predicted massive at-scale adoption of consumer-grade technology interfaces in the workplace. We wouldn’t have predicted a massive shift in terms of role of the CEO at a time of social-justice reckoning. And I think that experience sufficiently chastened people in thinking about leadership to say, “Hey, rather than just a set of skills that we’re hiring to do a set of known tasks—so grow market share here, plant the flag in this market—we are hiring someone who we hope we can point at that sort of stability. But you start to see words like character, resilience, curiosity show up more and more and more. And that obviously puts our teams—our [industrial and organizational] I-O psychs, our assessors—put a lot of energy into trying to figure out who is the person? How will they respond under adversity? Because there will be adversity. How will they respond to change? How will they respond to disruption? How will they accept the fact that every workplace is as deeply divided as the societies around us? And just those sorts of what I would call—in addition to the biographical features and experience features—the attributes, the “who is this person?” element seems to be getting dialed up as a result of that inherent unpredictability and recognition of inherent unpredictability.
Fuller: You’ve heard recently about cost transformation, how to manage that at the corporate level. What are the two or three takeaways for our audience members who have decision-making authority over some part of their organization? What do you say to them are the implications for them of trying to get to these new frontiers in the economics of the enterprise?
Monahan: The hard part is not taking cost out. The hard part is keep making sure the enterprise is healthy and thriving in the subsequent time period. Did we take out costs in a way that allowed us to sustain the work we did and sustain it on a relative basis? And that has some really interesting longitudinal cultural elements: how you source the ideas, how you think about a total transformation, how you achieve buy-in, how people across the organization understand why that’s a competitive environment, how you enlist them as co-conspirators, in an effort to change the economics of the enterprise, because our data is very clear that the overwhelming majority of cost takeout initiatives fail by the standard of sustainability. And some fail in a far more catastrophic way, which is, not only is the cost advantage not sustainable, they impair their competitive position in the process. It’s a tricky act for a leader, because you sometimes have to acknowledge that not everyone who’s signing up to help with the task has a role on the other side. But in a very low-trust period in our societies and workplaces right now, you actually gain some trust advantage by saying, “This is a competitive necessity, and we’re going to take it on together. And we’re doing it for a really important reason, because it enables us to fulfill a mission and a purpose that, if we don’t fix our cost structure, we will not have the ability to fulfill.”
Fuller: I did some research actually with an Accenture partner a few years ago, and one thing we found was that, if an executive had been in a company, or the company they still worked in had done a major transformation previously, less than half of the executives were prepared to essentially buy into the next transformation program—that they were deeply skeptical, they actually were thinking more about the impact of the next transformation on their immediate teams and colleagues than falling into line and saying, “Yes, we can do this. Yes, I understand that we’ve got these objectives.” My memory is, about 41 percent fell into that category, and that there were three other categories, including people who would be essentially almost actively aggressive detractors and impeders of it—literally a majority of the people who’ve got to implement what you want being skeptical or negative about what you’re trying to accomplish. I don’t know how to manage in that setting.
Monahan: I think I’ve learned the hard way that saying to a group of people, “We’re going to move our margin structure from X to 1.05X” motivates no one. As opposed to starting with, “Our company exists for a reason, and that reason is this.” That reason could be “We save human lives in a hospital setting.” It could be “We deliver better lives through lower-cost products and retail setting.” And there are a series of attributes necessary to do that in perpetuity and better, and one of them is this. This is an enabler of that thing, because, ultimately, I think people can get excited about that in service to the larger idea—that is, an enabler of something we all agree is work worth doing seems to help quite a bit.
Fuller: Another manifestation of how AI is going to affect work and workplace, I think, is the indirect impact it’s going to have on education. Now, you were a CEO in the sector at DeVry. When you think about the growing skepticism, a lot of people about the value of a university degree, when you think about what your clients are looking for in candidates and what they believe they get for their trouble in hiring a university graduate, as opposed to what they’re consistently disappointed doesn’t seem to come with a package, how do you feel about the role of higher ed going forward? How do you feel about whether or not it’s creating people with the right balance of skills and aptitudes—both social skills and technical skills—that are going to be candidates that your clients are going to find attractive?
Monahan: We probably at various points as a society over-fetishized university degrees. The mantra became: Not only is a university degree really important, it’s really important at age 18. And the pendulum, I think, is a reappraisal of both of those things, because I think they’re separable, right? If you look at DeVry, an overwhelming majority of our students were adult learners. And I think that’s incredibly healthy. People have said, “Hey, there’s certain skills I need. I now have enough work experience to know either I want to go farther faster in my job, and I know now what it’s going to take,” or “I don’t like my job, and I want to go do that job over there, and I know what that’s going to take.” Hopefully this shows up as a reappraisal of DeVry’s alternative pathway for a lot of students who at a different point in their lives and careers are now engaging and finding access in ways that are convenient, efficient, tightly linked to workforce outcomes. And yet, at the same time, all the rigor, accreditation, lattice work, the ability to have durable professional skills—whether that be critical thinking, problem solving, communication, clarity of thought, clarity of ability to collaborate effectively. And so, I think the idea of a university education is still a really powerful way for someone ... I think some parts of it are a luxury product. I was lucky enough to enjoy the luxury—it’s fascinating, it’s exciting, it’s interesting—and there are parts of it that should make you a stronger member of society and the workplace. Absolutely. And I think you’re seeing us, as a society invests for the first time in the U.S., look at other ways of creating platforms that give people economic opportunity and recognizing there’s lots of other ways for someone to get and build a great career. So I think the pendulum has swung a little bit too far—I think probably led to some good reappraisal of the cost of education, the timing of education, the objectives of education. But I also know that the rigorous structure and holistic approach of a university is very appropriate for an awful lot of people, not all of them at age 18.
Fuller: Tom, one last question. As you think about the next decade, even next quarter-century, what do managers need to be prepared for? When you think about the broad trends— not, is there going to be a pandemic or not, but what is leadership going to look like in 10 or 15, 20 years? And what kind of skills should people be cultivating and what kind of talent should organizations be trying to stockpile?
Monahan: Sure. I think probably the first most obvious challenge is leaders are going to be leading organizations that have human workers, contingent workers, and digital workers. I think, secondly, the relentless inquiry around what is it only humans can do? Because getting that titrate between the different categories correct requires honest inquiry around the limitations of each category. A third thing that I think we’ll have to think a lot about—we don’t talk a lot about—is that in most, if not all, of the developing world, the working-age population is going to shrink. So if we don’t have a productivity boost, we’re going to have a very hard time growing these economies. So if it weren’t for AI, the thing we’d all be fighting about is the demographic crisis that is accelerating in all of our industrial economies. Period. Full stop. And the only reason we can indulge the AI conversation is because it’s made it possible to imagine we might escape that demographic crisis. But that will create interesting dynamics in terms of stratification between generations in the workplace. I think that’s going to be a really interesting dynamic for leaders to have to manage—and swirling that up with technology as well. And so I think leaders are going to have to lead across boundaries. There will be boundaries of all sorts. We mentioned generational. Building a global organization will become different and harder as you think about how you allocate work, how you motivate work, how a geopolitical rivalry makes its home. Even within societies, you witness different realities in how people react to what they see in society. So leading across boundaries that are going to become more pronounced, I think, is going to be a challenge for leaders in the future.
Fuller: Well, Tom Monahan, CEO of Heidrick & Struggles, it’s always a pleasure to talk to you, and thanks for sharing those thoughts with our audience on the Managing the Future of Work podcast.
Monahan: All right. Thanks very much.
Fuller: We hope you enjoy the Managing the Future of Work podcast. If you haven’t already, please subscribe and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts. You can find out more about the Managing the Future of Work Project at our website hbs.edu/managingthefutureofwork. While you’re there, sign up for our newsletter.
