Skip to Main Content
HBS Home
  • About
  • Academic Programs
  • Alumni
  • Faculty & Research
  • Baker Library
  • Giving
  • Harvard Business Review
  • Initiatives
  • News
  • Recruit
  • Map / Directions
Faculty & Research
  • Faculty
  • Research
  • Featured Topics
  • Academic Units
  • …→
  • Harvard Business School→
  • Faculty & Research→
Publications
Publications
  • 2023
  • Working Paper
  • HBS Working Paper Series

'It Wouldn’t Have Mattered Anyway': When Overdetermined Outcomes Justify Our Sins

By: Stephanie C. Lin, Julian J. Zlatev and Dale T. Miller
  • Format:Print
  • | Language:English
  • | Pages:50
ShareBar

Abstract

We identify and document an “overdetermined outcome defense” which occurs when one learns that circumstances besides one’s own actions were sufficient to produce a negative effect (e.g., deciding not to go to the gym, but later discovering that the gym had been closed anyway). We present seven preregistered studies (total N = 3784) examining the nature of this effect. In Studies 1 and 2 we find people felt less guilty when they discovered that a negative outcome following a self-standard violation “would have happened anyway” than if no such information was available across a variety of scenarios (Study 1) and spontaneously in a thought generation paradigm (Study 2). Studies 3 and 4 suggest this effect has both rational and motivated components. In Study 3, the overdetermined outcome defense was used for both others and the self, but more for the self, and in Study 4, the participants admitted that they would use the overdetermined outcome defense more than they felt they should. In Studies 5A, 5B and 6, we tested behavioral implications of this effect in self-control and prosocial behavior contexts. We found that, when people chose options that violate their self-standards over ones more consistent with their self-standards, guilt motivated them to actively seek overdetermination to justify their choice. In Study 6, we once again found that discovering that a negative outcome was overdetermined reduced guilt in participants in an incentive-compatible decision context. Our findings contribute to the literatures on outcome bias, justification, and irrational acquiescence.

Keywords

Moral Sensibility; Decision Making; Outcome or Result; Behavior

Citation

Lin, Stephanie C., Julian J. Zlatev, and Dale T. Miller. "'It Wouldn’t Have Mattered Anyway': When Overdetermined Outcomes Justify Our Sins." Harvard Business School Working Paper, No. 23-045, January 2023.
  • Read Now

About The Author

Julian J. Zlatev

Negotiation, Organizations & Markets
→More Publications

More from the Authors

    • March 2023
    • Faculty Research

    Río Curicó Teaching Note: Video Short I

    By: Kathleen L. McGinn and Julian Zlatev
    • February 2023
    • Faculty Research

    SIMmersion: Simulating Crucial Conversations

    By: Alison Wood Brooks and Julian Zlatev
    • 2023
    • Faculty Research

    Sending Signals: Strategic Displays of Warmth and Competence

    By: Bushra S. Guenoun and Julian J. Zlatev
More from the Authors
  • Río Curicó Teaching Note: Video Short I By: Kathleen L. McGinn and Julian Zlatev
  • SIMmersion: Simulating Crucial Conversations By: Alison Wood Brooks and Julian Zlatev
  • Sending Signals: Strategic Displays of Warmth and Competence By: Bushra S. Guenoun and Julian J. Zlatev
ǁ
Campus Map
Harvard Business School
Soldiers Field
Boston, MA 02163
→Map & Directions
→More Contact Information
  • Make a Gift
  • Site Map
  • Jobs
  • Harvard University
  • Trademarks
  • Policies
  • Accessibility
  • Digital Accessibility
Copyright © President & Fellows of Harvard College