Does Front-Loading Taxation Increase Savings?

John  Beshears; James J. Choi; David  Laibson; Brigitte C. Madrian

Article | Journal of Public Economics

Does Front-Loading Taxation Increase Savings?: Evidence from Roth 401(k) Introductions

by John Beshears, James J. Choi, David Laibson and Brigitte C. Madrian

Abstract

Can governments increase private savings by taxing savings up front instead of in retirement? Roth 401(k) contributions are not tax-deductible in the contribution year, but withdrawals in retirement are untaxed. The more common before-tax 401(k) contribution is tax-deductible in the contribution year, but both principal and investment earnings are taxed upon withdrawal. Using administrative data from eleven companies that added a Roth contribution option to their existing 401(k) plan between 2006 and 2010, we find no evidence that total 401(k) contribution rates differ between employees hired before versus after the Roth introduction, which means that the amount of retirement consumption being purchased by 401(k) contributions increases after the Roth introduction. A survey experiment suggests two behavioral factors play a role in the unresponsiveness of contribution rates to their tax treatment: (1) employee confusion about or neglect of the tax properties of Roth balances and (2) partition dependence.

Keywords: Saving; Retirement; Taxation;

Format: Print

Read Now

Citation:

Beshears, John, James J. Choi, David Laibson, and Brigitte C. Madrian. "Does Front-Loading Taxation Increase Savings? Evidence from Roth 401(k) Introductions." Journal of Public Economics 151 (July 2017): 84–95.

Career Karma is a startup focused on helping individuals looking to transition careers into computer engineering roles or similar fields by preparing them for formal technical training programs, or “coding bootcamps,” that would lead to a successful career pivot upon graduating from the program. The platform also encouraged users to engage with each other in “squad” support groups and paired users with mentors (other users who successfully transitioned careers through Career Karma). This case explores the journey of Career Karma’s three founders and navigating growth through an unexpected recession caused by a global pandemic.

Roughly half of Americans live paycheck to paycheck. When financial shocks occur during their working life, many of these households tap into their retirement savings accounts. We explore the practical considerations and challenges associated with helping households accumulate liquid savings that can be deployed when urgent pre-retirement needs arise. We propose that this can be achieved cost effectively by automatically enrolling workers into an employer-sponsored payroll deduction “rainy-day” or “emergency” savings account, and we explore three specific implementation options: (a) after-tax employee 401(k) accounts, (b) deemed Roth IRAs under a 401(k) plan, and (c) depository institution accounts. We evaluate the pros and cons of each approach and conclude that all three approaches merit exploration and field testing. We refer practitioners interested in seeing each implementation option discussed in its own self-contained section to the version of this paper distributed as NBER Working Paper No. 26498.

Faculty & Research

Does Front-Loading Taxation Increase Savings?: Evidence from Roth 401(k) Introductions

Abstract

Citation:

About the Author

More from the Author