Information Provision and Innovation: Natural Experiment of Herbal Patent Prior Art Adoption at the United States and European Patent Offices

Prithwiraj  Choudhury; Tarun   Khanna

Working Paper | HBS Working Paper Series | 2018

Information Provision and Innovation: Natural Experiment of Herbal Patent Prior Art Adoption at the United States and European Patent Offices

by Prithwiraj Choudhury and Tarun Khanna

Abstract

We exploit a natural experiment to study how codifying information about prior innovation affects subsequent innovation. A codified database of traditional Indian herbal formulations was adopted by the European Patent Office (EPO) and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) at different points in time. The database, the Traditional Knowledge Depository Library (TKDL), was created by state-owned Indian R&D labs to provide patent examiners searchable “prior art” drawn from ancient Indian medicinal texts. Using a unique dataset of herbal patents filed between 1977 and 2013, we find that adoption of the TKDL affected the level of herbal patent filings and grants and shifted the nature of patenting away from pure herbal formulations, similar to those in the ancient texts, toward combinations of herbs and synthetic compounds that were less similar to the prior art and apt to be less contestable.

Keywords: Patents; Plant-Based Agribusiness; Ethnicity; Health Care and Treatment; Pharmaceutical Industry; Agriculture and Agribusiness Industry; China; India;

Language: English

Format: Print

55 pages

Read Now

Citation:

Choudhury, Prithwiraj, and Tarun Khanna. "Information Provision and Innovation: Natural Experiment of Herbal Patent Prior Art Adoption at the United States and European Patent Offices." Harvard Business School Working Paper, No. 14-079, February 2014. (Revised January 2018.)

How does the organization of patenting activity affect a firm’s patenting outcomes? We investigate how the composition of patenting teams relates to both the scope of their patent applications and the speed of their patent approvals by examining the main effects of team members’ intra-organizational diversity (based on affiliations with formal organizational units and informal organizational communities) and the moderating effects of team leader experience. We test our moderated mediation model in a sample of 121 teams that filed patents in a Fortune 50 company’s India R&D center between 2005 and 2015 using proprietary employee data combined with newly released micro-data from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). Our findings illuminate the micro-foundations of innovation in firms by highlighting a trade-off between organizing patenting activity to maximize scope versus speed.

ISRO, India’s space agency, established to address domestic challenges with space technology, is one of the six largest space agencies in the world. Through its 59 missions, ISRO has launched numerous satellites for communication, disaster management, navigation, scientific exploration, and other diverse purposes. Its commercial arm, Antrix Corporation, which launches satellites for both domestic and international customers, has 0.6% of the global space launch market. However, there is increasing demand for satellite launches from both the Indian government and commercial organizations. Unfortunately, ISRO can neither manufacture the required number of launch vehicles to support the huge demand for its services nor can it launch them. In light of these constraints, what should ISRO prioritize? How should we think of this question in light of the theory of exploration-exploitation? What kind of human capital resources should it develop? What processes need to be strengthened? What external collaborations need to be fostered? Teaching Note for HBS No. 617-062.

Faculty & Research

Information Provision and Innovation: Natural Experiment of Herbal Patent Prior Art Adoption at the United States and European Patent Offices

Abstract

Citation:

About the Authors

More from these Authors