Valuation of Bankrupt Firms

S. C. Gilson; E. S. Hotchkiss; R. S. Ruback

Article | Review of Financial Studies

Valuation of Bankrupt Firms

by S. C. Gilson, E. S. Hotchkiss and R. S. Ruback

Abstract

This study compares the market value of firms that reorganize in bankruptcy with estimates of value based on management's published cash flow projections. We estimate firm values using models that have been shown in other contexts to generate relatively precise estimates of value. We find that these methods generally yield unbiased estimates of value, but the dispersion of valuation errors is very wide—the sample ratio of estimated value to market value varies from less than 20% to greater than 250%. Cross-sectional analysis indicates that the variation in these errors is related to empirical proxies for claimholders' incentives to overstate or understate the firm's value.

Keywords: Valuation; Business Ventures; Insolvency and Bankruptcy;

Format: Print

32 pages

Find at Harvard Read Now

Citation:

Gilson, S. C., E. S. Hotchkiss, and R. S. Ruback. "Valuation of Bankrupt Firms." Review of Financial Studies 13, no. 1 (Spring 2000): 43–74. (Abridged version reprinted in The Journal of Corporate Renewal 13, no. 7 (July 2000))

In January of 2019, Joe Heieck (HBS ‘ 14), CEO of gWorks, was deciding whether to proceed with his acquisition of Data Tech, that was a business roughly the same size of gWorks. gWorks, which provided geospatial software to small city and rural county governments, was acquired by Heieck in January 2015 after a 6 month search. While there were potential synergies between gWorks and Data Tech, the acquisition also presented some significant risks including its relatively high price and concerns about the need to modernize its product offerings.

Talismark negotiated waste hauling contracts for small and medium size companies. Its owners, Charles Muszynski and Marshall Staiman, were able to grow the business by more than 30% per year since it was founded, but believed that further growth and improved profitability were limited by the company’s approach to sales and its information infrastructure. They were considering reengineering its sales process, operational structure and information technology. These changes involved $1 million in estimated out-of-pocket costs. Beyond those costs, the decision presented considerable risks as Talismark would need to interrupt is sales efforts, replace its sales team and launch new approaches to sale and operations. The reengineering plan would transform Talismark into a new more efficient operation, but its owners were not sure whether the benefits of the plan would exceed its costs and were worried about the inherent risks.

Robin Kovitz (MBA 2007) acquired Baskits, a Canadian gift basket company, in October of 2014. The business was highly seasonal with two-thirds of its sales occurring in November and December. Baskits dealt with its seasonality by renting additional space at a different location and hiring part time employees in the peak season while operating in a smaller space and with fewer full time employees in the off peak season. Kovitz experienced firsthand the inefficiencies resulting from operating in two locations, inefficiencies that were exacerbated by the lack of an information technology system. She realized that operating from a single larger location year-round would resolve these inefficiencies. She also viewed an ERP system as critical to control costs through better management of purchase orders and inventories. Kovitz had to decide whether, and how quickly, to implement these changes.

Faculty & Research

Valuation of Bankrupt Firms

Abstract

Citation:

About the Authors

More from these Authors