Climate Rising

Scaling High-Integrity Nature-Based Carbon Removal with re.green

Climate Rising podcast avatar

Marcelo Medeiros, co-founder and CEO of re.green, joins Climate Rising to discuss how his company is restoring millions of hectares of degraded land in Brazil’s Atlantic Forest and Amazon biomes by producing high-quality nature-based carbon removal credits. Marcelo explains how re.green combines data science, forest restoration, and long-term land ownership to deliver durable carbon sequestration—and why they chose a for-profit model to scale impact. He discusses price transparency, quality verification, and how re.green is preparing for a future where compliance carbon markets may accept removal-based offsets from nature-based solutions. Marcelo also shares how winning the Earthshot Prize brought global visibility, how AI is improving ecosystem planning, and how the company works with clients like Microsoft and Telefónica under long-term offtake agreements. This episode is a part of our Global South series. Explore more episodes at climaterising.org.

Resources

Transcript

Editor's Note: The following was prepared by a machine algorithm, and may not perfectly reflect the audio file of the interview.

Mike Toffel:

Marcelo, thank you so much for joining Vikram and me today here on Climate Rising.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Pleasure. Mike and Vikram. Nice to be here.

Mike Toffel:

Great. Why don't we begin with an introduction. So you're a co-founder of re.green and we'll be talking about that organization in a moment, which is a voluntary carbon market supplier of carbon credits. What was your background and how did you get to that space?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Okay. I was an entrepreneur, a banker, a private investor, then an investor on my own with a permanent capital company. And I came across a scientist that was developing a model for designing where we should restore tropical forests if we were to restore them for profit, for carbon sequestration and for other co-benefits like biodiversity and helping the local communities. That was a very interesting article published in Nature in October 2020 by Bernardo Strassburg, the author of the article, that this could be a business given the value of carbon credits for offsets. And so we started this conversation and that's the origin of re.green.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. Great. So, you came at it from a financing perspective rather than a forestry experience or a climate activist perspective?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Exactly. I was the finance private-acting investor part of the business; Bernardo was the science. Bernardo was a data scientist, so at this point we also called in, we reached out for scientists that knew how to do the boot-on-the-ground type of restoration that understood how to do it. So, we brought in two leading scientists in Brazil, Ricardo Rodrigues and Pedro Brancalion that also joined us and the company really started, they brought in more researchers, the company really started with me with a finance background, an investment background, and eight PhDs that understood restoration and that's the beginning of the company. The first employee that we had that was not from finance or from science was the COO of one large pulp and paper company in Brazil that understood how to plant trees in a large scale in the large land plots. So that was pretty much the beginning of the company.

Mike Toffel:

Great. So, a real multidisciplinary team it sounds like?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Yeah.

Mike Toffel:

Great. Let's zoom back out and talk about Brazil.

Vikram Gandhi:

So the whole debate about the global south is how the global south, countries like Brazil and other parts of the global south kind of balanced this whole agenda of development versus decarbonization and deforestation. How is that playing out in Brazil and how is that decision made as to whether something in the Amazon should be deforested in the name of development or not? How is that playing out in Brazil right now?

Marcelo Medeiros:

I think Brazil has what I would say is one of the best, if not the best forestry code in the world. It's very strict. It defines in a thoughtful way, where should we preserve, what can we clear down? And not only Brazil has more than 50% of its total land area preserved in the form of parks, indigenous reserves and reserves that each landowner is forced to keep, but also there is a general culture of preserving some biomes. So, this is good. The problem is that compliance is not very good. We have a compliance problem. So, the forestry code, its excellent, society is behind it, but the compliance is weak. So, the forestation that we see currently seen in Brazil, it's mainly due to illegal activities, land grabbing, illegal mining and not due to forests being cleared for good economic reason that's supported by laws and regulations.

Vikram Gandhi:

One of my students yesterday in class, not from Brazil, but a Ghanaian student asked me, that there's an opportunity to do extensive gold mining in Brazil given where the markets of gold are but that would involve a significant amount of deforestation, but the revenues from the gold would help the infrastructure and the local communities there. And she asked me that question, how should I think about it? So how would you think about that?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Yeah, that's a hard question, but in the grand scheme of things, I don't think that what's pushing for deforestation are activities like legal, well-organized mining. If you look at how much we have deforested, we deforested pretty much 50% of habitable land in the planet, maybe 2 or 3% for infrastructure including mining. So that's not the main driver behind deforestation. So, I think the legal organized mining is perfectly compatible with preservation.

Vikram Gandhi:

So how do organizations like yours or any organizations in terms of nature-based solutions address this problem at scale? Because you said that deforestation is happening at scale, so how do we reverse that at scale?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Yeah, let's take a step back and talk again about the article that Bernardo Strassburg wrote in 2020 and that's the origin of re.green, it says a lot about our purpose and how our vision for productivity. As I said, we have cleared out roughly 50% of the regional biomes on the habitable part of the land. The United Nations called the decade from 2021 to 2030 the decade of restoration. And it has talked about a plan for restoring as much as 30% of the converted land. That's probably too much. So, this article looked at what, if we were to restore 15% of the converted land, where should we do it? And it looks at if we are maximizing for carbon sequestration, if we're maximizing biodiversity, if we're maximizing for other co-benefits like water cycles.

And so the article looked at this and concluded that one, it's perfectly feasible to restore 15% of the converted land without any pressure on food security or in any other activity. As I said, infrastructure for instance is a very small portion of the converted land. So, the first building block is that it's perfectly possible to have a large scale restoration in the world without putting pressure on food security.

If we zoom into Brazil and look at the situation we have in Brazil, it's become even more clear. Brazil has 160 million hectares of pastures. We have the largest cattle herd in the world, but we are not the largest beef producer because we're very inefficient, which means that we are using too much land to produce the amount of beef that we could produce with maybe half the land we're using. So of the 160 million hectares of land that we're using for cattle ranching, we could reduce this by 50%, we could use 80 million hectares for cattle ranching. The other 80 million hectares could be converted into agriculture or restored to a new regional biome. That's where re.green comes in. So let's, the playing field that we have are these 80 million hectares of land. And-

Vikram Gandhi:

I believe that there's a soybean issue as well which is very similar to the cattle issue in terms of, because that's another huge source of income for Amazon, the deep Amazon area.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Yeah, but that's not driving deforestation anymore. That's not deforestation, because I think that's a concerted effort in the words to track where the soybeans are coming from, now we're tracking where the beef is coming from. So it is not a good economic bet to deforest land in the Amazon to start a soybeans operation because you have the risk of not being able to sell soybeans and being penalized for having done that. So farmers are well organized, big farmers are not doing this. There are some land grabbers that typically go into public lands, clearing the forest in hope that one day they would get the title for that land. That's deforestation that's happening. It's not an organized deforestation from the agricultural sector in Brazil. Brazil has a very well-organized and efficient agricultural sector, especially in soybeans and corn and the like. So this is not where the pressure comes from.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. So just to reflect on one of the things you just said, putting some things together. So, you mentioned that deforestation is largely an issue of enforcement rather than of the law. And you said that deforestation that had been associated with soybean clearing for soybean development and even for cattle at least in the more recent years, has been reduced because of traceability programs, which I believe were set up by companies and by industry associations. And so in that case, this is, I think let me just get this right, this seems a lot like a success story of multinationals supply chain policies actually having a big impact on the ground to reduce deforestation. Am I understanding that correctly?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Perfect. That's the case. And the banks played a role too. Banks would not finance someone that was deforesting, even if it was legal and compliant with the code, banks would not finance the deforestation of Amazon to begin a soybeans operation in the heart of the Amazon. So limits were drawn of what are the limits of areas that could be deforested for soybeans and for cattle ranch operation. And they are respected by the large farmers, by the banks, by the organized society, but they're not respected by illegal activities.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. So, let's dive in a bit to re.green. So, re.green is a company again that's producing carbon credits for the voluntary carbon markets by planting trees in formerly deforested areas in Brazil, in the Amazon in particular. And it's an interesting space in part because there are so many carbon credits that are being produced in the world, but in particular in Brazil and also through forest related practices, whether it be preservation or deforestation, and I others are quite different, and often at low cost. And so one can find carbon credits on the market at $5 $7 of this general type compared to sequestration, like direct air capture technologies, which could be a hundred to a thousand dollars a ton.

And so this is a very attractive market in terms of cost of goods sold and prices, but Brazil and forestry have been the targets of quite a bit of media controversy and scandals about measurement, permanence, is it real? And so that's the space you're entering, which is an interesting space, with lots of potential but also lots of controversy. So, tell us a little bit about re.green's entry into that space and how it tries to take advantage of the opportunities while sidestepping the controversies.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Yeah, I think it touched on the fundamental point of the voluntary carbon market and for that matter of carbon offsets in general. And the numbers you used are exactly right, I say that a carbon offset can go from $2 to $1,000, that's a range.

And the reason is that every emission of CO₂ is the same. If you emit one ton of CO₂ to the atmosphere, it's immediately fungible, it mixes up in the atmosphere and regardless of how you emit it, where you emit it, it's going to be the same. It's going to cause the same damage, it's going to have the same effect, it's going to stay in the atmosphere for the same time. Every ton of CO₂ removed from the atmosphere, it's different in its own way. It's different for two reasons. It matters how you remove it and it matters how you store it after removing it. And that's the basic difference.

And another way to put this is to talk about additionality and permanence. So how you remove it is about additionality, how you store it talks about permanence. So, when we started re.green, we knew this and we also knew the scandals were very much related to nature-based solutions in the market of creating offsets by avoiding emissions. So, protecting a forest so the forest doesn't get cleared and so you avoid the emission that would happen if the forest was cleared, so that's avoidance certificates. We wanted to go into the space of removals, and we wanted to compare ourselves with the best standards that the industry has, the $1,000 removal. So, we wanted to make our removals clearly additional and clearly permanent.

To do this, we start by buying land and so we buy the land and sometimes land that has been deforested centuries ago, so in some cases 400 years ago when the Europeans landed in Brazil the first time, that's Atlantic forest, the first thing they did was start cutting the forest close to the coastline. So, we buy land that's used for cattle ranching, it's typically low productivity cattle ranching, that's what we go after. So, it's typically land that has been degraded. It had coffee plantation, sugar cane plantation, and cattle for a hundred years. It's unrecognizable. The pastures are of exotic invasive African species, so the forest would not come without active restoration. And so, we buy this land that has been a cattle ranch for generations, would continue to be a cattle ranch for generations if it wasn't for us to buy, that's additionality.

Then we use all the science and technology I talked about before, our scientists who use the best techniques and the best science available to restore that land to its original condition to the regional ecosystem, restoring all the ecological functions in the land plot. And then we create the legal framework around this to make sure that the restoration is going to be protected in the long run. Tropical forests have been on the planet for millions of years, there are no reasons why they could not continue to be on the planet for millions of years, even with climate change because those are dynamic systems that adapt to climate change.

So our goal was to prove that we could produce the same additionality and the same permanence that direct to air capture with mineralization for instance could produce. So, we went into this market trying to show that we have the highest possible integrity in our carbon credits and we had the product and then we looked for the buyers. So, we were not responding to an obvious demand in the market, we knew which kind of product we wanted to have and then we went to the market with the product we thought was the right product.

Mike Toffel:

Great. So let me ask just a couple of follow up questions here. When you talk about restoring the ecosystem, can you say a little bit what that looks like on the ground? I mean one thing that comes to mind is you're not planting a timber monocrop, throwing out seeds of just one type of species. I imagine you're using some diverse species, for example. Is that right? And what else does that mean?

Marcelo Medeiros:

That's totally right, and one of the most complex activities you can imagine, especially when we're talking... Because let me differentiate a little bit, there are some areas in the Amazon that have been deforested 40, 50 years ago where we have to do very little, where there are some basic activities that we have to do and the forest re-emerges because the deforestation is very recent and there are lots of forest fragments all around the land plot, so the forests just come back. When we talk about planting and forests in situations where I was just talking about areas that have been deforested 400 years ago, if you don't do anything, it'll continue. It had found another equilibrium, and it would take a very long time if it is to get back to the original condition. So we have to devise a plan to help the forest to emerge.

It's impossible to play God. You cannot just replant thousands of different species and bring back thousands of different fungi and insects and animals all by yourself by doing this actively, but you can create the conditions for the forest to reemerge. And that it's a decision on which plants, which trees to plant, when how with what density and it varies from area to area. It varies with the type of soil, with the climate, with the rain pattern, with the acclivity, the topography, it varies with the land use that you had before.

And so for each area we design a plan with all the knowledge that we have and we're getting better at doing this. At the beginning this was all manual, and it required people to go and checking and analyzing. And today after four years we already have this, we have been using an AI system with machine learning, and we are getting better and better. Today if you give me just the coordinator so of a land plot, I can come back in seconds with what would be a good plan to restore that area, knowing what the cost is, what the type of activities we would have to perform, and knowing the price of carbon, what the returns would be in that activity.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. So, let's talk about quality. So, I've never met a developer of carbon credit who said they were putting low quality credit on the market. So, everyone claims high quality or benchmark with others. And so, there's a challenge of trying to differentiate yourself from the pool and one way that some companies are pursuing is through the carbon rating agencies and we've done an episode on climate rising before with one of them. Is that a technique you're using? Are your carbon credit rated by these carbon credit agencies or is that not relevant to your market? How are you thinking about getting some sort of third-party validation of the quality story?

Vikram Gandhi:

One add-on to that is then therefore what is the implications for pricing for you, like you said, from $2 to 1,000? Where are you in that spectrum right now?

Marcelo Medeiros:

I think there are a number of layers I need to use to answer the question. The first layer is that there is a differentiation when you define what type of [inaudible 00:20:09] of credit do you have. So is it avoidance, is it removal? At the same time permanence is discussed with the certifier from the outset. So you describe what's the legal framework that you have. If you have a land plot that you have leased for 40 years, the maximum you can guarantee permanence is 40 years. If you buy the land and say that you're going to protect it and you have a budget for protecting them from fire, from invasion, from the reversal of the restoration, you can show that you can protect that for a hundred years. On top of that, if you do as we do, we have a plan for incorporating this into a national park or transforming that into conservation easement, you can say that you're going to go beyond a hundred years.

So from the very beginning, you might not hear anyone saying, "I'm going to produce a poor-quality credit," but you're going to say people saying, it's a credit for avoidance, it's a credit for 40 years. So, this is the first definition and we go to the highest category.

The second level is the rating agencies, and I think they're improving very fast, but I still think there are some gaps of understanding. So we have the highest possible rating in which one of the agencies that rate us and we do this and we incentivize them to rate us and we engage with them not because this creates any addition to the perceived value, it's not significant for us in terms of creation of value, but I think the development of agencies like this is going to be very good for the sector. So, we do engage with them, and we do get rated and we are rated with all the agencies that we know.

But the third and most important layer is the contract, the off-take contract. We don't sell carbon credits in the spot market. We sign long-term off-take contracts with large buyers such as Microsoft, Nestlé, Telefónica, and those are contracts that take two, three years to negotiate and they go to the nitty-gritty details of what we're doing, how we're doing, and then for how long we're doing and what's the budget and what's the milestones. And they go as long as 25 years and we have activities that we commit to undertaking for the 25 years of the contract. And I think that's the most important layer today is there are no clear standards. The way to resolve the question about quality, nobody confesses low quality, the way to resolve this is with a very well-structured contract.

Mike Toffel:

And there's only, as far as I know, only a handful of buyers who actually have the capabilities to do what you're describing. I mean, Microsoft and Amazon are two examples, google I know have developed, they have the whole teams working on this and so for those companies, working with them on a long-term contract where they're doing due diligence and partnering with an off-take agreement as you described, is a fantastic additional seal of approval, in a sense, most companies don't have that investment or have to rely on others say. So, I think it depends a little bit, but it sounds like you're pursuing all of these metrics, all of these approaches across the board?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Yeah. And I think the critical one is how the compliance markets are going to regulate the offsets going into compliance markets. When you define the standards of what the compliance markets would require for an offset to be used, then you're going to have standards that are going to be accepted across the board. It could involve ratings, it could involve special types of certifications, but then you have going to have a market that's going to be deep and liquid and it would have liquidity, but you need the standards and as you don't have the standards yet... But that's the case with most financial products. They start this way with very complex contracts and then become over-the-counter contracts and finally become tradable assets.

Mike Toffel:

Right, right. Let me circle back to Vikram's question about price premiums and add that you recently won the Earthshot Prize, which I imagine is another signal of quality. So, can you speak a little bit about the price premiums that you or others are seeing for quality? Because it's supposed to be a ton, is a ton, but as you suggested, $5 to $1,000 a ton suggests that the market is not perceiving a ton, being a ton, and presumably the higher quality ones are getting higher prices. I know that's not always the case, but hopefully we're going to drive ourselves in that direction. So, can you comment on that? And then also tell us a little bit about what the Earthshot Prize is and what you anticipate it means for you now having recently won?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Let me start with the Earthshot Prize, which was a great surprise. The Earthshot Prize is a prize created by Prince William and the Royal Foundation in 2020 it is a wordplay with the moonshot. And so they assumed that we have 10 years from 2020 to 2030 to repair the planet and they created a prize that gives one million pounds to each one of the winners in five categories each year. The category that we won the prize in was protect and restore nature.

Typically, they start with... They have 500 scientists and NGOs and business leaders that propose names to the Royal Foundation, to the trustees of the Earthshot Prize. They do a preliminary due diligence, they reduce the number to 150 and then a deeper due diligence and get to 15 finalists, three per category. And we were happy enough to be one of the three finalists, honestly. We were competing with the Tropical Forest Facility Forever, which is a Brazilian carbon initiative and with the Swedish entity Tenure that help indigenous populations to get title to their land, a very successful organization. So we were happy enough to be among the three finalists. I think it was an honor to be there and we really didn't expect to win.

So it was a great surprise when we won and it was very, very helpful because it gave us a lot of visibility. Also, people have started to pay more attention, as this is a prize that typically looks at innovative things that are being done. People wanted to find out what's so innovative about re.green. So, there was a lot of attention to what we do, the way we use AI, we use science to restore forests. And how complicated this is, people typically might associate restoring forest with something, a garden done at a large scale and it is very complex. So I think we've got a lot of attention, a lot of people analyzing this.

I think the premium, another question about the premium, given that on the other side of the table we have very knowledgeable buyers, the discussion is not so much about premium, why you're going to pay 5, 6, 10 times more than the $10 credit. That's not the discussion we have. The discussion is to explain what we're doing, what's the cost of doing what we're doing, and we have reached an agreement of what exactly is the product we can design for you. That's the discussion we've had with Microsoft. And we got to point in the discussion where we said, "Okay, I can do this, but it'll cost you X more." Or "I can reduce your costs by not doing this, if this is not important for you." We wouldn't do anything other than a high integrity carbon credit, so this is where we draw the line. It has to be an ecological restoration, meaning that we must restore the regional ecosystem in the place where you have degraded pasture, that's our product.

But within this product you have a lot of latitudes to discuss a lot of different features, including for instance, do you need that we protect the land for a hundred years, so this is going to cost that much. We're going to have a budget, we're going to have the legal framework and then we're going to protect it for a hundred years, but that's a budget for doing this. So, it's a discussion of, it's not really a cost plus, but it has some elements of cost plus because we discuss and we agree on what we're going to do, what the contract's going to be before deciding on the price.

Vikram Gandhi:

That's awesome. First, congratulations on the Earthshot Prize. I mean, that's a huge honor and hopefully it really, like you say, creates the visibility to actually help you scale up.

And talking about scaling up, and I'm guessing that given your client base or your contract base, given the explosion in AI data centers and therefore especially the gas-fired data centers that are happening here in the US, the actual demand for your carbon credits is actually only going up... So given that, I mean you had the option maybe of starting this as a non-profit, a lot of the deforestation are government projects, non-profits, you consciously have this as a business model that this is a scalable for-profit business model. We've talked about the asset side and the operating side of your business; now take us through the liability side. How have you raised capital? What have been the sources of capital and how do you see that evolving as you grow?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Okay, well first for-profit, we thought from the beginning that we had to be for-profit because it would be impossible to scale a capital-intensive business like this if we were a non-profit organization. So, when we looked at the business plan, this has to be for-profit and has to be very profitable or else we won't build up the capital to do it at the scale we want to do. So we started out with, that was my own investment firm that made the investment at the beginning with my business partner Marcelo Barreiro. Together, we founded the beginning of the company. Then when we had a good plan and all the infrastructure set up, we called a few investors and we selected investors that we thought would have the same kind of approach to this idea that we would have, very long-term investors that would be willing to participate in a very well-defined product, the high-integrity carbon market, not make profit at any cost, but only do the right thing.

So we approached these investors, and I was really surprised, I could barely finish any of the conversations I had. There were four investors that we called, all four said, "We are in," before we could finish the presentation.

Marcelo Medeiros:

So this was a great start for the company. We still have the same investors. We also had very strong support from the National Development Bank of Brazil, that thinks of stopping deforestation and incentivizing ecological restoration as one of their main missions today. They have a huge project within the National Development Bank to do this. So they were able to offer us credit lines that basically do not exist in other sectors or maybe in other parts of the world, credit lines for 25 years. So we don't have any refinancing risk. We match our costs and our cash flow to the term of the loan and we don't have refinancing risk on this. We are going to need more capital. So we're going to raise capital, possibly another round of private financing and hopefully this is going to be a public company someday.

Vikram Gandhi:

That's awesome. So in terms of one of the big questions of investing in climates, I wouldn't call you a startup now, but innovative climate solutions is that typically the initial investors are family offices, I'm not sure who the four were, but they're typically family offices that have a return objective but also passionate about climate the development financial institutions like you talked about the Brazilian bank. Have you evolved? The key question is how do you evolve from that kind of capital to classic institutional capital, whether it be on the private side or the bank side, and is your new round going to focus on that kind of capital or is it more family office and development financial institution?

Marcelo Medeiros:

That's a great question. I think it's hard to separate the impact element from the pure investment decision, but we try to propose to the investors something that doesn't depend on impact for them to make the decision. We try to show them a risk-return proposition that regardless of what we're doing would be appropriate. But inevitably the people that we talk to and the people that are interested in talking to us are people that value the impact very much.

Vikram Gandhi:

Of course.

Marcelo Medeiros:

So I have a little bit of difficulty separating, why they're investing, is it the impact, they just like the return. Maybe this will continue all the way up to the IPO. Maybe the IPO people that come into this investment will be people that like the cause.

Marcelo Medeiros:

But we try to present to all them a risk-return that we think is valid regardless of the positive impact.

Vikram Gandhi:

I understand. One of your big sources, main source is the voluntary carbon markets and having these long-term contracts and you're just coming back from, our understanding, is from COP30 in Brazil. Tell us a little bit about some of the discussions that you've seen there, both in terms of voluntary carbon markets or other topics that may have interested you.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Well, re.green had six people at a COP with different objectives. So, people from re.green that were just talking to potential buyers, having discussions about possible commercial contracts, people talking about finance opportunities, people doing some benchmark with things that are happening all over the world. So, I was given a number that at any given at COP you may have more than 400 events at the same time, so you have to divide, so each one of us looked for one thing. Personally, what I was more interested in was talking to people about the transition from voluntary carbon markets to compliance markets.

Vikram Gandhi:

For our listeners, could you just maybe just define those two and what the key difference is?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Okay. The voluntary carbon markets, basically companies responding to their stakeholders and saying, "Shareholders, suppliers, clients, I'm a carbon-neutral company. I'm a good company, I'm responsible." So, it's something that the companies decide to do it themselves, therefore voluntary and they do it for the sake of satisfying stakeholders.

The compliance market is something that's regulated, it can be a carbon tax, it can be a cap and trade system, but something that a jurisdiction regulates and says, "In our jurisdiction, we're going to be carbon-neutral by such date, and to do this, we are going to impose those taxes or caps on how much you can emit."

Vikram Gandhi:

Great, thank you.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Today we have 80 different jurisdictions with some form of carbon tax or carbon trade, some form of compliance markets. The acceptance of carbon offsets is very, very limited and the acceptance of offsets from nature-based solutions, which are much more complicated to regulate, even smaller.

However, if you look at the problem we have at hand, which is the 50 gigatons of emissions, there's no scenario in which anyone would even dream of proposing that we're going to reduce emissions to zero. Typically, you say we're going to reduce emissions as much as we can and there's going to be some emissions that's going to be very hard to abate and we are going to have to remove the CO₂ from the atmosphere. Not to say that ideally, we would continue to remove to reduce the current level of concentration of CO₂ we have in the atmosphere. So compliance markets will have to deal with this. We need both. We need to reduce emissions as fast as possible, and we need to develop methods for removing CO₂ from the atmosphere. The numbers, the most optimistic numbers in terms of reductions, reduce emissions from 50 to 10. So 10 gigatons would have to be removed. That's a huge, huge, huge number. So how are we going to get to these 10 gigatons of removals depends on how we regulate the compliance markets.

Vikram Gandhi:

I understand. And did you see in COP the discussion of going from volunteer compliance, like a productive discussion or was it just talk?

Marcelo Medeiros:

Discussion is starting and my role in the discussions is to talk to compliance markets that are already organized and discuss what would it take for them to accept credits from removal and more specifically credits from removal that come from nature-based solutions. So that's the discussion I'm interested in. There is a lot of work to be done. This is not simple. And as we said, we were talking at the beginning, you can draw the line anywhere in nature-based solutions. You can say that we will only accept nature-based solutions that can guarantee with 99.5% of chance that this is going to be storing carbon for a hundred years. That's one standard. Or you can say, "No, 30 years is good enough because if we can buy ourselves 30 years, then we can find all the solutions 30 years from now."

So this decision is a decision that's based on what you believe in in terms of technology, how fast it can evolve, what's the importance of nature-based solutions to human beings? Are we happy with a situation where we have no biodiversity, no original ecosystems and a lot of big machines removing CO2 or do we want to balance this? So, once you take those decisions, then you create the standards. Once you create the standards, you can have acceptance in the compliance markets.

Mike Toffel:

That's awesome. So, what are some early movers? Who are some early movers among countries who are contemplating or maybe have already begun accepting nature-based solution carbon credits as part of their compliance scheme?

Marcelo Medeiros:

I think virtually all large compliance markets have some form of ongoing discussions about how to accept offsets. The European market, Japanese, Singapore, I think they all have ongoing discussions. How soon are we going to get to an effective solution? Hard to say, but hopefully within the next three years, I think ideally, you're going to start some strong movements of credits going into at a reasonable volume into the compliance markets.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. Great. Well, let me step back. So, you're here at Harvard for the year as a climate action fellow at the Harvard Salata Institute. It's your second year at Harvard because you were here the year before in the Advanced Leadership Initiative program.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Correct.

Mike Toffel:

That's where we initially met. So, tell us a little bit about what you're doing this year as a climate action fellow and then in that role, I'm sure you're dealing with students or other young professionals perhaps who might be intrigued by re.green and your path and want to work in this space. So, two questions in one. Tell us a little bit about your agenda for the year here at Harvard and the advice that you would give such people, of course, whether at Harvard or elsewhere, who are among our listeners who are interested in this space.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Okay. Well, my first year here at Harvard was pretty much devoted to learning. And the interesting thing is not learning something that has been discovered centuries ago or years even years ago, it's participating in the learning process. The discussions are ongoing discussions. The discussions about economics of climate, the policies in climate, even climate science is something in the making. So, it was a fantastic year because to be part of the be involved in the learning process where you're learning as the knowledge is being built, it's being created.

The second year I'm involved in the Salata Institute, I'm a climate action fellow, and my role, I have multiple roles. I try to help as much as I can with the connections between the Salata Institutes and researchers, policymakers and business leaders around the world. But I'm also coordinating a group of carbon offsets that's a multidisciplinary group to try to understand what the shortfalls are, what are the problems, what does it take to make carbon offtakes something viable and meaningful contribution to the climate mitigation.

You asked about advice on people that want to get more involved. Well, first, I think this is probably the best time of the year to get involved in climate because all the newspapers are talking about this. You have the COP; you have a lot of information coming out. And so, one thing I recommend is to try to follow closely what's coming out of the event.

I think it's going to be more productive to start reading about this when they produce something, which is after this coming of the weekend of the 21st. After that, you're going to start to see the decisions, the conclusions, and what was decided. A lot of analysis is going to come, so I think this is a great way to get involved. The United Nations website, the IPCC reports, those are wonderful documents. They're very lengthy but knowing that nobody is going to read a thousand-page document, they have very good executive summaries that are very helpful. And finally, I think the Salata Institute website has a lot of information, a lot of activities, programs for mentoring students, programs for helping students to find activities at Harvard and even MIT to get involved in climate action. So, I also highly recommend that you look at the Salata Institute website.

Mike Toffel:

Great. And we'll post a link to that in the show notes. Great, Marcelo, thank you so much for joining us on Climate Rising and Vikram, thank you for co-hosting with me.

Vikram Gandhi:

Thank you, Mike. Thank you, Marcelo. I appreciate it.

Marcelo Medeiros:

Great to be here. Thank you.