Climate Rising

Regenerative Agriculture at Scale with Tom Brennan at McKinsey - Part 2

Climate Rising podcast avatar

Tom Brennan, a partner at McKinsey & Company, joins Climate Rising to unpack what regenerative agriculture means in practice and why it is increasingly central to conversations about climate resilience, farm economics, and food system risk. Drawing on McKinsey’s work with farmers, agribusinesses, and food companies, Tom explains how regenerative agriculture differs from more prescriptive models like organic farming, emphasizing outcomes such as soil health, reduced erosion, and long-term productivity. Across this two-part conversation, Tom explores both the foundations of regenerative agriculture and the challenges of scaling it. He discusses how farmers evaluate new practices through the lens of risk and profitability, why the benefits of regenerative practices often show up most clearly in extreme weather years, and what slows adoption despite growing interest. He also examines the role of food companies, insurers, data, and emerging technologies in lowering barriers to adoption and supporting system-level change.

Resources

Transcript

Editor's Note: The following was prepared by a machine algorithm, and may not perfectly reflect the audio file of the interview.

Tom Brennan:

I'd characterize almost like three types of unlocks that could help accelerate, I'll call it the speed of scaling. So you need to find trusted advisors of the farmers, agronomists, et cetera, that can be educated, that can be empowered in a hopefully more scalable manner. And the second one is just make it a better business case for the farmer. And then finally, I think the third bucket is, well, is there a way to finance the bridge? And so if we recognize that the business case or the two-year or the three-year payback might not be there for the farmer, but we're pretty comfortable over a five, 10-year time horizon that they're going to be able to make it back, how do we think about financing instruments to help farmers?

Mike Toffel:

This is Climate Rising, a podcast from Harvard Business School. I'm your host, Mike Toffel, a professor here at HBS. This episode continues my two-part conversation on regenerative agriculture with Tom Brennan, a partner at McKinsey & Company, part of the broader climate rising series on regenerative agriculture. Last episode, Tom and I explored the fundamentals of regen ag, what it is, why it matters, and where it can create value for farmers. Today, we turn to some more difficult questions. Why hasn't regenerative agriculture scaled faster? What barriers are farmers facing in making the transition? And what can companies, investors, and policymakers do to accelerate adoption of regen ag practices? I'll ask Tom to unpack what McKinsey's research reveals about the practical challenges and realistic pathways for scaling regenerative agriculture.

Here's the second part of my conversation with Tom Brennan from McKinsey. So you've been wonderfully indulging me in these conversations at the farm level, but you opened earlier mentioning that McKinsey typically doesn't directly work with farmers, but work at the distributor level, at the input level, elsewhere in the supply chain, the consumers of crops and so on, which are the General Mills of the worlds and so on. So can you tell us a little bit about where do you do work in this space? Because it sounds like it's not consulting to farmers recommending the practices that they do based on the soil chemistry of their fields.

Tom Brennan:

No. We are not farming. So there's a few different reasons that people have gotten excited about this. And so we referenced earlier ... I'd say this was five years ago, this was top of mind. Well, is this a big opportunity to build a carbon business around? Because we can think about gigaton levels of carbon that could be sequestered in the soil that might not be sequestered there today. Is that an opportunity potentially? And that's one where I think the debates within the scientific community, as well as all of the bodies around what is a top tier carbon credit. There's simply not enough agreement around those concepts in order to, I'd say, get true scale there at this stage.

What we've also seen with regenerative is we talked a little bit about, well, where do you see the benefits most prominently as a farmer? It's in those drought years. And we also think about agriculture as a lot of water, but it's only about 15% of US agricultural land is irrigated, meaning 85% is rain fed at the mercy of whatever the weather might be for a given calendar year. So if you're downstream of those farmers, all of a sudden regenerative agriculture might look like a nice way to reduce your exposure or volatility of saying, "Look, I'm dependent upon these grains that are being grown in the hundred miles around my processing facility. Last year was rough. I was struggling to get all the volume I needed. Prices went up 2X. Is there something that I can do?" So it becomes this procurement strategy where regenerative can be a solution. It's like, "Well, you need to think about how you're working with your farmers. What are they doing to mitigate their downside risk?"

And then I think the other area of interest is downstream. And you can relate this to the carbon conversation, but the companies were saying, "I recognize that some of the biggest footprint that my products have is the agriculture that was done to produce the raw materials. Is this a way that I can be improving the water that surrounds the farms that we're working on that reduces the associated fertilizer application and imply carbon footprint from a scope three emissions perspective?" So I think those were all some of the threads that we had with clients up and down the value chain. And I think there's probably one other aspect here too, which is ... And to consider this a qualitative benefit versus a quantitative, but as you went around and you talked to the companies that have made big commitments in this space that have really gone after regenerative as an opportunity within their supply chains, they've probably gotten to know their farmers a lot better.

The flip side of this is complex, you need to work closely with the individual farms, the individual farmers in order to pull this off. If you're able to do that, it means you've developed a very close relationship to someone who's critical to your supply chain and your ultimate business success. So I think that's one of the ancillary benefits from the companies that are going down this road that maybe wasn't the original impetus, but is something that they've welcomed.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. And this is somewhat predicated on the fact that transportation is a non-trivial cost. And so using the farms within, say, a hundred-mile ring of a processing plant is much better than saying, "Oh, I'll just import it from three states away because you bear much lower transportation costs." Is that right? Because otherwise, why would local matter?

Tom Brennan:

Yeah. You're moving a lot of water around, you're moving a lot of stuff with limited shelf life potentially, depending upon the crop. So it always varies by value chain. Iowa might be a big agricultural state, but we haven't figured out how to grow coffee there.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. Okay. So some of the values you talked about were variability of supply/a resilience strategy, a cost play, efficiency passing some of the cost savings on perhaps. And then you mentioned also about pollution, like water runoff and pollution. So what's the take there? Why would a multinational, for example, be concerned about water pollution adjacent to the farms from which they ultimately procure?

Tom Brennan:

Yeah. That's going to be your context specific. And if you're the big company in town, your name's on the buildings, companies associate this with social license to operate. Are we being a good steward of our communities? Because if they're centered around some of these processing plants, that means their employees are fishing in these rivers. Their groundwater is going to be impacted by high levels of nitrogen runoff. The air quality, that's another big one when you think about the nitrogen goes into the soil, it turns into nitrous oxides that get into the air. It's an air quality issue. And increasingly, we've also seen legislation regulations even at the local and state levels associated with reducing groundwater pollution. And then all of a sudden that becomes an issue from the availability side as well of saying, "Geez, if practices don't change, our ability to source economically and consistently might be impacted."

Mike Toffel:

Right. Right. So we've talked a lot about the barriers and some of the upside opportunities. I wonder if you can speak to some of the scalable solutions that you're seeing. Are there collaborations or consortium among farmers or among folks further down the supply chain, the multinationals or the consolidators or the mills who are banding together in some way so that they're not all making the same mistakes individually, but rather maybe sharing resources or learning from each other or any other ... What's the upside potential here? How do we get out of this unfortunately small equilibrium that we're in right now with farmers? Even though you mentioned some of the practices are growing, it still seems low relative to the opportunity.

Tom Brennan:

There's a lot of untapped potential. Yeah. Yeah. And we put a big number on it in the article. That's where the math led us. And you think about it, right? It's in year as well as land value over time. So if we're just framing this as an economic opportunity for, let's focus on the US right now, economic opportunity to the tunes of 10s, potentially hundreds of billions of dollars in wealth creation. Okay. That's exciting. We can say there's all these side benefits that are also great, but maybe harder to put hard numbers around, but from the economic perspective, this is something that we should be excited about. So I'd characterize almost like three types of unlocks that could help accelerate, I'll call it the speed of scaling as well as what sorts of levels we ultimately get to. We talked a lot about like this is complex, there's a lot of local nuance, there's not a silver bullet. So you need to find trusted advisors of the farmers, agronomists, et cetera, that can be educated, that can be empowered in a hopefully more scalable manner. So how do you do this even though solutions are local, not global at the end of the day? So I think that's a big one.

And you mentioned like, how are different parts of the value chain interested in this? Well, you think about a retailer or distributor that has that close relationship with the farmer that often is providing agronomic advice. They would see this as how to evolve that further. And the second one is just make it a better business case for the farmer. And we said, "Okay, look, in a 10-year time period, farmers should do this, but well, what about in a five-year time period? Can we make the business case even better? So can we come up with markets for the cover crops, for example?" This is something where we're starting to see movement around cover crops to biofuels. So you can harvest the cover crop, you're generating something useful. It's not just there providing cover, it's providing useful biomass that can be extracted and sold as well.

Next would be the ecosystem services, whether it's carbon, biodiversity, water quality. Again, hard to see certainty at this right now, but if we get any of these markets to scale, we'd think it would be beneficial to the farmers that are following regenerative practices on the insurance side. And this is a complex area when we get to how does insurance and downside protection work for farmers. But if we're seeing some of the biggest benefits in the worst years like drought seasons, should we be thinking about if you're an insurance company, if you're providing insurance to farmers, do they look like a better opportunity? Do they look like a better customer for you? And is that being properly recognized? And then the equipment side. And so can we get the equipment more automated, less expensive, more efficacious, et cetera? That's something that reduces the upfront cost.

And then finally, I think the third bucket is, well, is there a way to finance the bridge? And so if we recognize that the business case or the two-year or the three-year payback might not be there for the farmer, but we're pretty comfortable over a five, 10-year time horizon that they're going to be able to make it back, how do we think about financing instruments to help farmers?

Mike Toffel:

Great. And you described many of these in the reports that you've put out, which we'll put on the show notes of the show so people can learn more about some of these unlocks. It's really interesting. So how optimistic are you that we're going to see scaling up in this domain? So even though we might lay out all these things that need to happen, this list might not have been that different five years ago. So do we expect the same list to be there five years from now or do we think these are changed? One of the things that just comes to mind offhand with the agronomist localizing knowledge, it seems to me with the advent of AI and large language models and figuring out from a variety of science and other types of discoveries about what's working under what circumstances, that being able to process that information and translate it into specific prescriptions, that coupled with remote sensing, satellite data, drone data, being able to monitor things more cheaply, watching a bunch of experiments, that's different now than it was a few years ago and I think that's only going to get more and more interesting over time. So maybe that's one domain that gives us more hope for the near future, but what do you think about that or other differences?

Tom Brennan:

The direction of travel, I think is a positive one. If we go back to, well, what's being measured, what's being measured in mass, I should say. Some of these, like the cover crops, for example, consistently growing, albeit from a small base, but if you rewound 10 years, you'd say, "Okay, we're moving things in a positive direction here." And we think about, "Okay, can we create markets for those cover crops? Even better." That should accelerate things even further. And all of a sudden we're going to have people investing in better genetics then for the cover crop. So not only can I plant an oil seed, but I'm planting an oil seed that's 30% more productive than the seed I was given 10 years ago because people are actually developing breeding programs around some of these second crops or second harvest for my climate. So I think that's one positive direction.

I do think this whole thing around the complexity, how do we manage complexity? How do we make things more localized, more recommended, more tailored to local farmers? Certainly this may be an opportunity for things like AI. Agriculture in general is a great space for AI solutions because it's data rich, lots of unstructured data, it's messy, it's an open system, it's really hard. There's not some simple linear regression that tells you what to do as a farmer for the most part. It's based off of lots of data. Some of that, we go back to that agronomic advice, which is good agronomic advice is worth its weight in gold. And can we get greater scalability out of some of the top-notch agronomists out there and things like LLMs might tap into that. That's an area that companies within the industry have demonstrated an interest in. Okay, how do we think about leveraging gen AI for some of these applications and traditional AI as well?

So I think that those are some of the reasons that we might think of, okay, the practices are going in a single direction. The technology enablers are clearly there. And as with all things, this isn't something that easily goes viral. However, it doesn't mean that if you see it, you won't start believing it. If it's working for your neighbor and you get the chance to observe it over three, five, 10 years, you might be convinced. It doesn't happen overnight, but I think it does happen in time.

Mike Toffel:

Yeah. Interesting. We've talked a lot about the definition, the barriers, some of the opportunities. Let's talk a little more about McKinsey itself. So I know that consultancies are remiss for ever naming clients, and so I'm not asking that, but if you can tell us in a more general sense, or however specific you're able to be, about a few client engagements in this domain. What does that look like for those who are interested in thinking about, maybe there's a opportunity to work in consulting in this space? If you can just take us through a couple of examples.

Tom Brennan:

Yeah. Given the broader topic of the podcast, Mike, as someone that worked in renewable energy, many years ago, you think about sustainability and climate as areas of interest, you look at agriculture and the food and agricultural system's about 25% of greenhouse gas emissions. And so what I tell a lot of younger colleagues that are saying, "Well, how do I do sustainability work in agriculture?" Well, if you're increasing the productivity of a system that's 25% of all emissions, you're doing sustainability work at the end of the day. So I think helping the entire value chain become more productive, more efficient, that has benefits very much in line with how we think about the benefits of regenerative agriculture specifically. So whether that's scaling new technologies ... And I contrast some of the complexity of reaching these regenerative practices and adapting how you farm to saying, "Hey, look, it's the next generation of seed, or it's a better formulation of a pesticide that you know works pretty well." Those are a little bit easier to scale. They don't happen overnight. It takes a few years, but farmers are used to getting better products. And so how do we help companies figure out the right parts of the world to target?

It's about figuring out, okay, sometimes it's county level of, this is going to be an area we should spend a lot of time at as a commercial organization because the pest pressure there has been very high in the last few years and your product has a very compelling solution against that. So that's the top of the value chain. And then I think further down, it's around how do you think about better conversion of what farmers are producing into useful products. And so it's always more about doing more with less. And in the context of agriculture, I think the framing that I like to use is I grew up in a world where we're worried about producing enough calories. It wasn't that long ago. You can probably go back just 10 years ago and it was, we're going to have 10 billion people in 2050, how are we going to feed the world? And for the most part, we've solved that problem. We're not short of calories. It doesn't mean we're getting those calories to everyone that needs them, but we don't see a limit or we don't see a ceiling in terms of how much food we can produce. It's all about now, how do we produce that food? How do we do so more sustainably? And how do we make that food as nutritious as possible? So I think those are some of the macro questions that the whole industry is dealing with.

And then you layer on, well, what's going on geopolitically, what's going on with climate disruption? Every year feels to be a little bit different, which I guess makes it interesting. And then you also layer on these technologies. So we talked about breeding programs for better cover crops and what does gene editing mean for this? Can you increase the fatty acid composition? Can you increase the oil composition of a given crop that makes it more valuable wherever it's grown? How do we think about AI again? So AI could be on the acre, it could be up and down the value chain within the companies as well, how are they adopting that and in the context of agribusinesses? So that's a little bit the 30,000-foot view of what's going on. But I think some of the themes that we see that aren't explicitly tied to regenerative agriculture are still very interesting questions for the industry that we get to work with clients on that ultimately have the same types of impacts for the world.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. So some of these examples are real examples of companies coming to you saying, how do we improve the stability of our input streams given droughts and so on? Or how do we think about improving the nutrition of the grains that we're procuring? And you're partnering with them to try and help figure that out.

Tom Brennan:

Exactly. Or if you have something that's a better solution, how do we bring it to market? That's a very common one upstream of saying ... And it's always fun coming from a science type background of, well, it's technically a better product. It's just going to succeed, but it usually takes a lot more than that to win in the marketplace.

Mike Toffel:

Yeah. For sure. Great. Good. Okay. Well, this has been a really helpful overview. Tell us a little bit when folks ask you, as I will now, for resources, if listeners here think, "Wow, regen ag, this is a really interesting area. Where can I learn more? Are there podcasts? Are there newsletters, websites? How can I learn more about the McKinsey practice?" Can you just give you a moment to shine with both your broader suggestions as well as narrower suggestions as well?

Tom Brennan:

If you Google McKinsey ag, you'll probably get pretty close just with that. That has our repository of articles we've published over the years. And so the one regenerative might be of interest as well as the ones of how do you decarbonize agriculture and how you decarbonize different parts of the economy more broadly, just thinking about the different solutions and how I'd say cost-effective are they? We like to think about things in terms of dollars for metric tons abated and you start to say, okay, there's some low hanging fruit in the world of agriculture in terms of things like reducing fertilizer runoff, et cetera, that at least are exciting in a way because that shows that there's opportunity which is economically beneficial irrespective of what the cost of carbon is.

Other resources, there's definitely some good podcasts broadly about what's going on in the industry. One of my favorites is future of agriculture. And so that's wide spanning content there with interviews with people across the industry doing lots of interesting stuff. So whether it's regenerative, new technologies, new business models, good pulse on what's going on.

Mike Toffel:

Are there conferences, like industry conferences people could find their way toward?

Tom Brennan:

World AgriTech is one where we attend every year in San Francisco and they have regional ones as well, but the world conference is every March out in SF. And what's interesting about agriculture, and I contrast that with chemicals because that's one practice that I spend time in that industry too, there's not one ag convention where everyone's at. So it's a little bit of, well, if you're an equipment company, you might be going to AgriTechnica. If you're in the fruit and vegetables, there's some European conferences as well where you can learn around how everything's harvested, how it shipped, how it's displayed in the supermarkets. So again, it's a very diverse industry crop by crop and then step of the value chain by step of the value chain.

Mike Toffel:

Got it. Great. Well, Tom, thank you so much for sharing your thoughts, sharing your wisdom. It's been a really interesting, wide-ranging conversation. I really appreciate you spending time with us here on Climate Rising.

Tom Brennan:

Thanks so much for having me, Mike.

Mike Toffel:

That was the second in my two-part conversation with Tom Brennan, partner at McKinsey & Company on the challenges of scaling regenerative agriculture. You've been listening to Climate Rising. I'm your host, Mike Toffel. Sophie Wong produced today's episode. Craig McDonald is our audio engineer. We'll be back in two weeks with another episode of Climate Rising. See you then.