BiGS Actionable Intelligence:
LAS VEGAS — The United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America (UBC) is tailoring its recruiting to attract the variety of new members that will allow the 500,000-member union—with many aging members—to thrive and expand.
This fresh approach entails a range of efforts: outreach to attract women and other underrepresented groups in construction, targeting high school students who do not want to attend college, and using more innovative recruiting methods.
UBC must grow to meet an expected demand for carpenters created by three pieces of legislation signed by former President Joe Biden, which together contain more than $1 trillion for new construction. President Donald Trump has sought to freeze funding for some of the projects, but federal judges have thwarted that effort.
Douglas McCarron, president of the UBC, says he views the work of recruiting a less homogeneous membership as both challenging and promising.
“When I talk to the journeymen, I say, ‘Look, I’m an Irish guy. We’ve got Hispanics. We’ve got Blacks. We’ve got women. We’re going to need more of them if we’re going to grow,’” McCarron said. “There’s no room for discrimination in this union.”
Diversity in union labor
Unions overall have become more diverse. The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) made history in 2023 by electing its first Black female president, April Verrett. But jobs in construction and trades have long been associated with white men, something unions and other groups are trying to change. The Million Women in Construction Initiative, announced by former Secretary of Labor Gina Raimondo in 2022, calls for doubling the number of women in construction. Groups like Women in Skilled Trades are also working to bring more gender diversity to construction and trades.
The International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) sees diversifying its membership as essential to growing its membership, said Louis J. Antonellis, business manager and financial secretary for IBEW 103.
“It’s not only the father-son, centuries-old model,” Antonellis said. “Eight to 10 years ago, we had to refocus how we go out and grow our membership—more women, more people of color. Since we’ve focused on that, we’ve never been stronger.” In 2023, the Boston-area local chapter had the most diverse apprentice class in its history.
“If we’re not going to change and have our membership look like the rest of the community, we’ll be left behind,” Antonellis said.
So far, UBC’s efforts to boost diversity have produced mixed results.
For example, the union has seen remarkable growth in Hispanic members. They account for 80% of new membership in Southern California and about 64% of new membership in the southern United States, said Pete Rodriguez, vice president of UBC’s western district.
At the same time, the percentage of female members remains low. Throughout the construction industry, only about 6% of workers are women. For example, UBC industrial scaffolding expert Jacqueline Engle has worked for years as the only female on the union’s job sites around Las Vegas.
“I still haven’t had the opportunity to work with a sister,” Engle said, “which I would love to do.”
A new generation of carpenters
Like the IBEW, the carpenters union modernized its outreach to attract a broader group of workers. The UBC is looking for “first generation carpenters,” traveling to high schools, community colleges and other recruiting pools that don’t fit the traditional model of union construction workers. The effort has meant more women, Hispanic and Black workers are being attracted to the field, according to the UBC.
Increasing the ranks of female members was a priority for McCarron even before he became president. When he worked as a UBC business agent in Los Angeles, he noticed the hard work by waitresses in the coffee shop he visited each morning. McCarron said he thought people with that work ethic would make excellent union members. He recruited three waitresses from the café to join, and they became specialists in acoustical tile work.
UBC employs two women at the international level whose full-time jobs are signing up female members, according to McCarron.
Recruiting is critical
To find both diverse and more traditional prospective members, UBC leaders continually recruit. That entails going to high schools and community colleges to talk with counselors, administrators, teachers, and even football coaches. It also means a focus on underserved communities, said Peter Rodriguez, vice president of the union’s western district, which covers 13 states.
Rodriguez said he tells high school counselors that he understands their gold standard is educating the next doctor or astronaut, but that they are far more likely to be educating the next construction worker. He advocates for apprenticeships for students who do not want to attend a four-year college but do want to become construction workers. “Let’s make sure they become the best construction workers they can be,” he tells the counselors.
Apprenticeships are also good for employee retention, according to North America’s Building Trades Union. Fully 91% of apprentices who complete their programs are still employed nine months later, the group said. Apprentice training is also cost effective. For every dollar spent on training, the company earned between $1.30 and $3 in profit, the 14-union group said in a report on apprenticeships.
Trump has shown an affinity for “skills-based” hiring. In his first term, Trump signed an executive order downplaying the importance of college degrees for certain government jobs. Biden also promoted the idea of good-paying jobs for those without college degrees.
One of UBC’s goals is to recruit younger members, lowering the average age of people joining the union from 27 to 25 1/2, Rodriguez said. That requires starting more prospects in apprenticeships at a younger age so they can complete their training, become a journeyperson, and be eligible to join the union.
A lesson from the football world
When Rodriguez thought about how to improve UBC’s recruiting, he decided to find more inventive methods than job fairs. One day, he was watching the National Football League’s “Combine” on television, where all top prospects are invited to a four-day camp to be evaluated in a variety of areas. He noticed that the emphasis was not on football skills but rather on more general physical skills, such as sprinting and weightlifting, and on mental skills.
Something clicked. Rodriguez thought that carpenters could do something similar.
“It’s important that the apprentice coming into the trade understand that you don’t have to know the trade itself. You’re going to be taught that,” Rodriguez said. “But what you do need is some pep in your step, a good attitude, balance, and the ability to move and take instructions.”
Rodriguez and his staff set about creating a carpenters’ combine, where they tested a candidate’s abilities in areas such as moving materials, following directions, and balance. The events are busy, hands-on affairs that provide a pop-up experience — a temporary event in an unusual space — that appeals to young people. The union aims to hold these in the same zip codes that are generating lots of carpenters’ work, to increase chances that the new apprentices can get jobs near their homes.
Each event has led to hundreds of young people of different ethnic backgrounds signing up for apprenticeships.
When it comes to recruiting, Rodriguez said, “there’s no excuse for not being creative.”
READ THE NEW VOICE OF LABOR SERIES
Bipartisan engagement with Big Labor may signal new era of unionism
Recent overtures suggest new alliance between labor and conservatives
Carpenters’ union leader committed to collaboration, leadership training
Federal legislation could keep carpenters working at historic levels
Union sets ambitious goal: transforming job site culture
The future of labor: Empowering workers (but perhaps not unions)
