BiGS Actionable Intelligence:
When Colorado coal miner Matt Cooper learned that the facility where he worked for 29 years was closing, he naturally considered new careers in energy. But he quickly found that wind and solar facilities had few jobs in the area, and those that did exist would require a pay cut.
Then he learned about the promise of the geothermal industry and its shortage of drillers. Taking advantage of programs in his state, he established a company that capitalizes on his skills and can employ his whole family.
“You start thinking, ‘this job is going away — what’s next?’” Cooper told The BiGS Fix. “[The geothermal industry] has the potential of growing pretty substantially.”
Cooper’s story is an example of what policymakers have termed the “just energy transition,” a nationwide effort to ensure that longtime energy workers and the communities where they live are not left behind as the world moves toward clean energy and away from coal and other fossil fuels.
Yet as companies, governments, nonprofits and academic institutions work together in many places to create programs, experts who study the issue say these efforts are generally understaffed and underfunded.
Gunnar Trumbull, a Harvard Business School professor who studies green industrial strategy and how business and government work together on climate change, said workers in fossil fuel industries should be addressed as America’s energy profile changes.
“We have a responsibility to support those who lose their livelihoods as a part of the green transition,” he said. “They are as much victims of climate change as are the homeowners displaced by rising seas or growing threats from wildfires.”
Coal: The big example
Tony Mazzocchi, a leader at the now-defunct Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers International Union, issued what may be the first call for a just transition in the early 1990s. He thought it was unfair when the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency shut down a plant making cancer-causing pesticides in 1987, spent $10 million cleaning up the site, but did nothing for the workers who lost their jobs.
He suggested a superfund for workers, including financial assistance and job training. The fund never materialized, but the concept took hold, not only for workers in the energy sector, but also for communities that suffer economic losses.
Coal is a good example of an industry in which both workers and communities are being impacted. Coal accounts for about 9% of total energy consumption in America, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Its production reached a peak in 2008 but declined by nearly 50% by 2022, according to the Bureau of Business and Economic Research at the University of West Virginia.
Energy production and employment in the industry has been shrinking for many reasons. Chief among them, Trumbull said, is price reductions in competing industries like wind and solar, which have made coal a relatively expensive option. Coal plants have also been targeted for closure because they emit high amounts of greenhouse gases, which are linked to climate change.
“When we add new capacity to the grid today, it is mostly solar and wind due to their low cost,” Trumbull said. “That means that we are likely to see a growing level of dislocation in the traditional coal and gas sectors.”
The Trump administration has tried to reverse the coal industry’s declining fortunes, issuing several executive orders that, among other things, prioritize the industry and shield it from regulation. The president invoked emergency powers to keep the coal-fired J.H. Campbell Generating Plant operating in Michigan after it was scheduled to close. He also tried to keep open the coal-powered Cholla Power Plant in Arizona, though officials eventually closed it, saying it was too expensive to operate.
Despite those efforts, employment in the industry has plunged and the industry continues to contract. In 2012, 90,000 people worked in the U.S. coal industry, yet in 2024 only 40,000 people remained, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. This year, 23 coal-fired units in 15 plants are expected to shut down, according to the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
A battle lost in Arizona
The closing of another coal power plant, located within the Navajo Nation in Arizona, prompted the creation of the Just Energy Transition Center at Arizona State University.
When the Navajo Generating Station and the coal mine that supplied it closed in 2019, nearly 1,000 people, mostly Native Americans, lost their jobs. The Navajo Nation lost about $40 million a year in revenues, and the Hopi tribe lost about $14 million.
The losses prompted Kris Mayes, then a professor at ASU, to found the center to help coal communities plan a new economic future. Mayes is now Arizona’s Attorney General.
Lauren Keeler, director of the center and associate professor at ASU, said coal facility closures are devastating. They take away jobs, reduce tax revenues, and force some of the most engaged members of the community to relocate for employment.
The Just Energy Transition Center convenes leaders from communities, local and state governments, economic development offices, and utilities to explore the impact of closures, potential mitigation measures, and funding solutions, she said.
“What we try to do is to help communities have conservations about who they are and who they want to be,” Keeler said. “We ask ‘what do you love about this community?’
In the case of the Navajo Generating Station, the center helped facilitate a $144 million payment to affected tribes and communities, which was to be paid by ratepayers of the utility that owned the power plant. In 2022, however, the Arizona commission that regulates utilities reduced the total to $40 million.
Keeler disagreed with the decision. “Legislators ought to fund this. Ratepayers should fund this,” she said. “We have all benefitted from low-cost energy. It’s not fair to abandon these communities.”
Colorado forges a pathway
Julia Haggerty, professor of earth sciences at Montana State University, said that a just energy transition is suffering from a lack of resources.
While the Trump administration has worked to keep coal mines and plants open, it has also reduced federal efforts to assist coal communities, including eliminating the federal Interagency Working Group on Coal and Power Plant Communities, and cutting programs from the Inflation Reduction Act and the Bipartisan Infrastructure Act, two bills passed by Congress during the Biden administration.
“We’ve taken a huge step back when it comes to the federal government,” Haggerty said. “Huge and important federal programs have disappeared and many people working in this area are no longer working. For the next few years, the states are the places we should look to for action.”
Several state governments, including those in New York, New Mexico, Minnesota and Colorado, have launched just energy transition initiatives.
Wade Buchanan, director of the Colorado Just Transition Office, said his office was created in 2019, when the state legislature was implementing ambitious clean energy goals. Legislators realized these goals, which would slash greenhouse gas emissions, would also lead to the closing of the state’s eight coal power plants and six mines. They wanted to reduce the harm that closures would cause.
Colorado’s coal facilities still employ about 1,700 workers. That is not a large number, Buchanan said, but the jobs are concentrated in small communities and pay so well that the losses could severely damage the local economies.
In addition, the shuttered mines and plants will no longer be paying taxes. “Some communities are going to lose more than half of their tax base,” he said.
In response, the Colorado Legislature allocated $30 million, earmarking about half the funds for individuals and half for communities.
In 2024, the Just Transition Office scored an early success by hiring legal counsel to represent two entities hit hard by the closures, the city of Craig and Moffat County. The lawyer helped negotiate a $73 million settlement for those communities with the owner of the plants and mines, Tri-State Generation and Transmission, a wholesale supplier.
The office also established a program allowing miners with more than five years in the coal industry to tap up to $11,250 in approved services, including education and training. Other services, including counseling, financial and retirement planning, are also available.
Only about 50 coal workers have engaged with the Just Transition Office so far, in part because the coal facilities are still operating. Buchanan hopes to expand that number.
“Our challenge is building relationships and building trust with people from traditional conservative communities that are distrustful of government,” he said. “Our answer is to prove sincerity by delivering what we promise.”
The journey of a mining family
Cooper, the 55-year-old coal miner who now makes his living in geothermal installations, worked with the Colorado Just Transition Office.
He comes from a family of energy workers, going back to his great grandfather, who drilled for oil and gas. For almost three decades, Cooper worked at the ColoWyo mine, named after Colorado and Wyoming, logging 14-hour days doing many jobs, including operating and maintaining machinery and serving as foreman.
Cooper said his experience operating drilling equipment will be a good fit for his new business in Hamilton, Colorado, called “High Altitude Geothermal.” Yet he also knew he and his family members, including his two sons, his daughter and his wife, needed additional training and information.
A “navigator” from the Colorado Office of Just Transition provided valuable assistance. “She helped me navigate the alphabet soup of state agencies and hooked me up with the Small Business Development Center,” which helped him write a business plan, he said.
Cooper is also benefitting from an economic development program, called Rural Jump Start, which provides tax relief and grants to businesses in areas affected by coal plant and mine closures. In addition, he was reimbursed by his employer for the class he took to earn a Commercial Driver’s License.
Starting his new career has required him to do many things he has never done before, such as buying expensive equipment and owning his own business. Behind all of it is hope. “We are hoping there will be constant work, and we can fill the need,” Cooper said.
His extensive preparation gives him confidence that he and his family will have a “smoother transition” to their new careers. “The Coopers are the kind of model we envisioned,” Buchanan said. “They are bound to succeed.”
