Editor’s note: The historically high tariffs and frequent changes that mark American trade policy have had a significant impact on companies and the overall economy. Harvard Business School Assistant Professor Ebehi Iyoha has done extensive research on the impact of U.S. policy, including how uncertainty impacts small business and the cost of circumventing tariffs. She talked to BiGS about the effects that tariffs have, how companies respond and how the business community feels. The interview has been edited for length, clarity and style.
How have tariffs impacted businesses?
We want to think separately about tariffs and tariff uncertainty. There’s often a gap between the announced tariffs and what ends up being charged. After you consider exemptions and rollbacks, business owners’ actual costs are often smaller than the announced costs.
The uncertainty of tariffs has been quite problematic for businesses because it’s shortened their planning horizon. In our survey, businesses report having to pull back on planned investment and hiring because they need to have more cash on hand or liquidity to deal with unexpected tariff costs.
One thing people often do not realize is that the timing for paying taxes and tariffs is different. For business taxes, you don’t have to pay up front. You earn money, then you pay taxes. If you have a tariff bill due, you’re not going to be able to get your goods until you pay, so that’s an upfront cost.
If you’re a large business that has robust credit lines, you might be able to manage that pretty well. If you’re a small business that has limited access to credit lines, then where is the money to pay tariffs going to come from? It’s going to come from the money you plan to use to expand, to get more customers, to do more advertising and to hire more people. So, there’s quite a bit of variation in the impact of tariffs.
What sectors of the economy have been impacted by tariffs the most?
The most trade-exposed sectors tend to be manufacturing, wholesale and retail. U.S. manufacturing relies a lot on foreign inputs in their production. Retail purchases a lot of products for their U.S. consumers that are not manufactured in the U.S. You also have product-specific tariffs. The auto manufacturing sector has been hit hard by steel and aluminum tariffs, and so has the construction sector. Steel and aluminum tariffs have ranged between 25 and 50 percent.
What options do businesses have to lessen the impact of tariffs?
Businesses can adjust on three dimensions: pricing, sourcing, and exemptions. My colleague [at Harvard Business School], Alberto Cavallo, has been tracking the pass-through of tariffs to consumer prices, and it’s actually been lower than expected because some retailers are eating some of the increased costs. They are squeezing their own margins so they can stay competitive and not lose market share. They are only increasing prices gradually.
People forget, though, that it is not just about how you deal with tariffs, it’s about how your competitors are handling tariffs. You don’t want to raise your prices if your competitors are not raising their prices, because you will lose market share. It can become a waiting game where some companies try to wait out competitors that have to raise prices immediately. But not all firms have to do that. If you are selling luxury goods, you might be able to pass on the full cost of the tariffs because you have customers willing to pay the increase. Some consumers consider higher prices to be an even better sign that the product is worth buying.
You can also seek new suppliers or renegotiate your contracts so you can reduce the tariff costs you have to bear. If you have a long-term relationship with your supplier. You can say ‘hey, why don’t you give me a 20 percent discount now that tariffs are 40 percent? You pay half of the tariff, and I pay half of the tariff.’ As you would expect, firms that are making larger orders and have had longer relationships with suppliers will have more bargaining power. In our survey of small businesses, we found that most of them do not expect to get a discount from their foreign suppliers.
Another thing you could do is change what country you are sourcing from so that instead of sourcing from a high-tariff country you source from a low-tariff country. That relates to research we did around Vietnam, which has dramatically increased its exports to the U.S. In some cases, companies are moving their production to Vietnam because of lower costs. In other cases, companies are trying to circumvent tariffs by relabeling goods that were fully made in China.
A third component is seeking an exemption through a lawsuit or an application. You need legal expertise and policy expertise. It is quite a process to go through. My colleague [at HBS] Lauren Cohen has an interesting paper that finds that firms that were most likely to get tariff exemptions had some kind of government expertise. They either hired people from the government or had government contracts in the past.
What do business leaders think of tariffs?
We did a sentiment analysis in our study about what business leaders think about tariffs. It was quite eye-opening for me. Just because you get increased costs from tariffs doesn’t necessarily mean that you are going to be against tariffs. The survey found that among business leaders , about 55% opposed tariffs, 20% favored them, and 25% had mixed views.
Why are so many business leaders willing to support or at least not oppose tariffs when they are hurting the bottom line?
In the very last quote at the end of the paper, a business owner says tariffs are painful but necessary to balance what others have been charging America. I think for a lot of people, it’s not immediately apparent what ultimately is the optimal or best response to China. There’s a sense that there’s a lot of uncertainty, and something needs to be done, but the right policy isn’t clear. So, for some business leaders in our study it’s not clear that the current policy changes are incorrect just because they are costly.
