Working Paper | HBS Working Paper Series | 2016

Revisiting the Classical View of Benefit-Based Taxation

by Matthew Weinzierl


This paper explores how the persistently popular "classical" logic of benefit based taxation, in which an individual's benefit from public goods is tied to his or her income-earning ability, can be incorporated into modern optimal tax theory. If Lindahl's methods are applied to that view of benefits, first-best optimal policy can be characterized analytically as depending on a few potentially estimable statistics, in particular the coefficient of complementarity between public goods and endowed ability. Constrained optimal policy with a Pareto-efficient objective that strikes a balance–controlled by a single parameter–between this principle and the familiar utilitarian criterion can be simulated using conventional constraints and methods. A wide range of optimal policy outcomes can result, including those that match well several features of existing policies. To the extent that such an objective reflects the mixed normative reasoning behind prevailing policies, this model may offer a useful approach to a positive optimal tax theory.

Keywords: Taxation; Policy;


Weinzierl, Matthew. "Revisiting the Classical View of Benefit-Based Taxation." Harvard Business School Working Paper, No. 14-101, April 2014. (Revise and Resubmit to Economic Journal.)